Have you heard about the Clarins 睫毛液 only remove in hot water. Mean you move clean your eye use hot water and will change to power. If you use oil or clean can't remove it.
Who try clarins before, pls let me have your comment.
HR is the best. HR's masscara is the most famous one in the world.
i use masscara eveyday & mine is very long.
i have tried lots brands & i believe HR is the best, especially the water-proof products. hope it can help u.