吹水玩樂

時事理財

由家出發

媽媽天地

育兒教養

情報分享

意見反饋

聯絡管理員

我的中心

Baby Kingdom - 親子王國香港討論區 › 首頁 › 自由講場› 求教(P5 英文題)

自由講場今日: 155|主題: 1299521

收藏本版

發帖

返回列表

跳至頁

樓主: sylcaca

求教(P5 英文題) [複製鏈接]

大茄

男爵府

積分: 6676

21^#

發表於 15-10-31 17:34 |只看該作者

other suggestions:-

Where my grandparents live is a big house.

The pop singer I like whose voice is sweet.

老師叉左晒兩句嗎?
還是一句?

私人傳訊

melonfans

珍珠宮

積分: 35145

22^#

發表於 15-10-31 17:53 |只看該作者

引用：Quote:原帖由 sylcaca 於 15-10-31 發表回

原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 15-10-31 發表
#2 都唔啱？真係要問老師……

subject 行先，subject 係pop singer, 佢用在i like 先，所以唔啱！subject 之後就要用 who, whose, where......呢句係possessive clause.

私人傳訊

melonfans

珍珠宮

積分: 35145

23^#

發表於 15-10-31 17:53 |只看該作者

引用：Quote:原帖由 Sumyeema1 於 15-10-31 發表

原帖由 melonfans 於 15-10-31 發表
subject 行先，subject 係pop singer, 佢用在i like 先，所以唔啱！subject 之後就要用 who, whose, where. ...

方麗娟啱

私人傳訊

birdbird

水晶宮

積分: 60447

24^#

發表於 15-10-31 18:00 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 birdbird 於 15-10-31 18:03 編輯

melonfans 發表於 15-10-31 17:53
方麗娟啱

呢句:
The pop singer whose voice I like is sweet.

本身係冇問題.

但係, 題目果兩句係:

I like the pop singer.
Her voice is sweet.

並不是 I like her voice!

所以 The pop singer whose voice I like is sweet 文法上是對, 但不對題.

'大茄' 提供的答案先至 o岩.

點評

大茄

發表於 15-10-31 18:41

私人傳訊

melonfans

珍珠宮

積分: 35145

25^#

發表於 15-10-31 18:07 |只看該作者

引用：2. The pop singer whose voice I like is

原帖由 birdbird 於 15-10-31 發表
2. The pop singer whose voice I like is sweet.

呢句分拆之後會得出以下兩句:

whose 係形容佢嘅聲音，所以subject 唔係I, 係pop singer. I like the pop singer, 呢句pop singer 係object.

relative clause 係要用subject 行先

私人傳訊

birdbird

水晶宮

積分: 60447

26^#

發表於 15-10-31 18:15 |只看該作者

本帖最後由 birdbird 於 15-10-31 18:21 編輯

melonfans 發表於 15-10-31 18:07
whose 係形容佢嘅聲音，所以subject 唔係I, 係pop singer. I like the pop singer, 呢句pop singer 係object ...
relative clause 係要用subject 行先

Relative clauses 用黎 describe a noun, 唔一定要 subject 行先.
樓主的題目, 個答案應是:I like the pop singer whose voice is sweet, 係屬於以下第2句 example.

A relative clause is a subordinate clause that begins with a question word (e.g. who, which, where) or the word that. You can use it to modify a noun or pronoun (i.e. to identify or give more information about it).

Students who can develop independent learning skills often achieve good academic results.
There is a new book that investigates the controversy over political reforms in Hong Kong.
A university is a place where people pursue advanced knowledge in specific academic disciplines.
The lecture theatre in which the inauguration ceremony will be held is now being cleaned.

extracted from
http://www2.elc.polyu.edu.hk/CILL/eap/2004/u6/relativeclauses.htm

.重申: The pop singer whose voice I like is sweet.
呢句分拆之後會得出以下兩句:
The pop singer is sweet.
I like her voice.

以上兩句跟題目原本兩句不同!

題目: I like the pop singer. Her voice is sweet.

sweet 是形容 the voice of the pop singer, 而不是 the pop singer!
所以, 個答案應該是
==>
I like the pop singer whose voice is sweet

私人傳訊