I have similar idea with you at the beginning. However, considering the ease and friendly operation, especically for my wife. I switch to buy an standalone HD DVD recorder as well.
Not sure ywpw case, if plan for whole family members use, I think the DVD recorder is a good choice. Mine is Panasonic EM60H, so far so good, bought in Chinese New Year.
Yes, 美女廚房, must be the first program I put in the timer. My wife and kid love it very much. But we should not at home that time. The DVD recorder is important to my family!