wow, your c6 still has name on the house? If does, tell your c6 ask his brother sell the house. If his brother don't want to sell the house. His brother should give your c6 back the 供樓 money.
Don't be mad of your mother-in-law to tell your c6 give 管理費 to his brother. I think she just don't want them argue.
I think you could count the market rent value (with management fee included) and substract the management fee $$ they have paid actually.....this is the actual rent to be paid........then divided the $$ by 2 --> the $$ to be paid by each party......then ask them to pay this sum each month, counting from the very 1st day they lived in that flat. Alternatively, ask them to pay the $$ your DH had paid to buy the flat lor ~~ the later is 一了百了 as your DH doesn't want to 計咁盡 gei 話 ~
Please do not quote any information posted by fungwongphie. 不誠實使用電腦會構成罪行,切勿以身試法。 何謂不誠實使用電腦??
卒之,後尾都放咗層樓,loss咗80萬,賣完還埋比銀行後,除三份每個party分番20萬...
It is unfair to your 62. I think you should give your 62 100萬 first, and then 分番 2 parts (if still have), one for your husband and the other for his brother.