論盡家傭

跳至

首頁
12

尾頁
   1


男爵府

積分: 8592


1#
發表於 11-4-11 13:56 |只看該作者
如題, thanks ~


子爵府

積分: 14415

好媽媽勳章 醒目開學勳章


2#
發表於 11-4-11 15:05 |只看該作者
回覆 BL715 的帖子

低過香港, 唔記得實際係幾多, 好似係$2000多(?)
我e + 個工人係係singapore 做過, expect 算叫有經驗, 識d英文.
但嚟到就有被騙的感覺, 咩都唔識, 最慘英文差到完全溝通唔到, 咁點教呀.
跟住同另一agent講, 佢話個工人係好ge, 一早俾人請咗去香港.
只有嗰d差到無人要的工人會到singapore, 騎牛揾馬,
因為兩地的人工同褔利差好遠.


大宅

積分: 1797


3#
發表於 11-4-11 15:10 |只看該作者
Yes, I lived in Singapore before. The contract is also 2 years, with no days off, no holiday ga!

They don't really need to know English, as some families are malay families, they speak Malay, not English.
Also, there are a lot of run away maids in Singapore, because usually the employers don't let them to go out at all, just put them in their house and do housework, so I will say maids from singapore are quite stupid too!


男爵府

積分: 8910


4#
發表於 11-4-11 15:38 |只看該作者
回覆 PY-Sing 的帖子

我又唔同意個 Agent 咁講, Singapore ke 文化同 印尼相近, 所以佢地多去 Singapore..!

我之前個印尼工人姐姐係 Singapore 做左 2年, 來到香港 very good, 英文中上, 溝通到..! 湊B 熟手 程度在我之上, 衛生程度也很好 (有時甚至比我更 aware). 慶幸我兩個小朋友, 初生時遇到呢位好姐姐..! 可惜佢幫左我 5年後, 要返去睇佢自己的小朋友..! 之後再請唔番咁好, 而家重遇到個公主.....!


大宅

積分: 1797


5#
發表於 11-4-11 17:02 |只看該作者
Yeah! It all depends on the luck!


複式洋房

積分: 287


6#
發表於 11-4-12 01:58 |只看該作者
回覆 manman0808 的帖子

YES. I AGREE.
MY 1st MAID WORKED FOR MIDDLE EAST 2 YEARS & SINGAPORE 2 YEARS. HER ENGLISH IS VERY GOOD & TOOK CARE MY NEWBORN GAL VERY WELL & CARING. I STILL MISS HER MUCH. I'M VERY REGRET DID NOT REPEATLY ASK HER TO STAY WHEN SHE TOLD ME SHE WANTS TO TAKE CARE HER TWIN GALS IN INDONESIA AFTER FINISHED CONTRACT. HER NAME IS IIS FATMAWATI / 33-yd old IF ANYONE IS HIRING HER NOW & THE CONTRACT WILL BE COMPLETED & WON'T EXTEND PLS TELL HER TO CONTACT ME OR PM ME. I REALLY WANT HER BACK.

MY 2nd MAID WORKED FOR SINGAPORE 2 YEARS COMPLETED CONTRACT THAT HER RESUME SAID SO.
I DOUBT IT AS SHE CAN BARELY SPEAK ENGLISH (SHE SAID SHE CAN SPEAK THE GOOD ENGLISH WHEN WE INTERVIEWED BY PHONE) & NO HEART TO TAKE CARE MY 2yr-old GAL AT ALL COS SHE EVER TRY TO TALK OR PLAY WITH MY GAL DURING 4 MONTHS WORKING FOR US (HER RESUME SAID SHE TOOK CARE NEWBORN GAL &
5-yd OLD BOY IN SINGAPORE). I TERMINATED THE CONTRACT WITH HER AFTER
4-MONTH COS SHE ALWAYS LOOKS AT THE MIRROR OR STAND IN THE DOORWAY IN THE MIDNIGHT WHEN ALL LIGHT IS SHUT OFF & WE SLEEP (SCARY) & I DO NEED THE MAID HAVE THE HEART FOR KID.

SO.....IT ALL DEPENDS ON LUCK.

BY THE WAY, THEIR SALARY IN SINGAPORE IS 250sg MEANS 1,500HKD & MY MAIDS ALWAYS HAVE 2-yr CONTRACT.

I THINK MOST OF THE INDO MAID WENT TO SINGAPORE / MALAYSIA COS THEY DON'T HAVE THE EXPERIENCE OVERSEAS BEFORE. THERE ALSO LOTS OF MALAY FAMILY THERE THAT IS CLOSE TO INDO.'S CULTURE. IF THEY EVER WORK OVERSEAS HONG KONG PEOPLE IN GENERAL WON'T PICK THEM AMONG THE SELECTIONS.



男爵府

積分: 8910


7#
發表於 11-4-12 04:25 |只看該作者
不過近年聽講, 新來的印真係差左..!


侯爵府

積分: 20752


8#
發表於 11-4-12 07:58 |只看該作者
我姐姐係星加坡做左 3 年, 佢話係完約 ! 乜原來星的合約都係 2 年 ?

佢的英文中上, 溝通到, 清洁各樣都普通, 完全唔識湊b, 煮餸普通... 不過身份成疑, 因為年紀和經驗都係佢講, 出生日期與實際不符, 無ref. letter, 舊僱主話搵唔到.....


大宅

積分: 2422


9#
發表於 11-4-12 09:50 |只看該作者
回覆 mango22 的帖子

Yes, you right.

For my case, my maid just working for us 1.5 years then she wants to goes back.
As i guess, she know in HK salary higher than singapore.

Also, in Singapore maid contract is 2 years old ( and no day off).

So, if any one employee maid, pls double check they are finished the controct or not.


大宅

積分: 2422


10#
發表於 11-4-12 09:52 |只看該作者
Also, In Singapore employee Indo Maid is up the price now.

B4 was Now
SGD:350===SGD450 ( no experience)


大宅

積分: 2422


11#
發表於 11-4-12 09:54 |只看該作者
Remind to everyone,, dont belive if the maid can do in Singapore must speak as well English......this is not ture.

Actually, in Singapore most of family not allow maid stay alone with kids, in the family usually have: MUM or older ppl to look around. SO, they are not really need to speaks well english. Also, in Singapore most of ppl can speak Malay,,, that why they can speak Malay to talk with maid.


寶石宮

積分: 254865

2025中秋節勳章 父親節2025勳章 母親節2025勳章 2025勳章蛇年勳章 2025勳章 2024年龍年勳章 2023年兔年勳章 15週年勳章 親子王國15週年勳章 親子王國15週年勳章 2021可愛聖誕B勳章 虎到金來勳章 2018復活節勳章 牛年勳章 2018母親節勳章 玩具勳章 BK猜猜猜慶中秋 BK Milk勳章 hashtag影視迷勳章 醒目開學勳章 環保接龍勳章 畀面勳章 最關心BB問題熱投勳章 Poo得好勳章


12#
發表於 11-4-12 10:22 |只看該作者
2007June-2009 June偷野印, 2 years Singapore, 2 years HK, 2 years HK, my mother's house 2 years, dirty, lazy, borrow money, steel, slow, black face, 拜神好鬼詭. got all worst maid's point. 捱2年完約唔續, Why don't fire her? 唔憤比多個月佢.


翡翠宮

積分: 82477

畀面勳章 環保接龍勳章


13#
發表於 11-4-12 11:25 |只看該作者
this is what I know, not sure if they have change the system.

they normally have 2 years contract. for the first year, employer give the salary to the agency directly and employer have to jst take care of the daily food and all for the helper.

I have heard cases that actually the helper doesn't get any money from the agency on the first year cos they have to pay back the agency .. very mean. That's why they prefer to come to hk.

As for living standard, Singapore governments flats (HDB) which are flats that most of singaporeans live in doesn't have helpers room. so a lot of helpers are jst sleeping in the kitchen with a bed, some who are nicer will give them a room, but that is not very often.

As for speaking english, yes a lot of singaporean speak at least a little malay - which is essentially the same as indonesian, so they don't have to speak very good english to be able to communicate with the employer.

and they dont have leaves at all. That part is very inhuman.


複式洋房

積分: 287


14#
發表於 11-4-12 12:30 |只看該作者
回覆 星星國媽媽 的帖子

WOW. GOING UP SO MUCH !!!
YES. MY MAIDS ALSO SAID THERE WAS NO HOLIDAYS AT ALL.


大宅

積分: 2422


15#
發表於 11-4-12 14:20 |只看該作者
回覆 gemiling 的帖子

Most of your point is correct but one point as you said that in Sg (HDB) flat let a maid to sleep in the kitchen,,,i think this is wrong. In SG(HDB) flat is very bigger and some of flat have maid room . Meanwhile most of singaporean doesnt like ppl sleeping in kitchen because they feel that kitchen is for cooking not sleeping.

As your last point, you said that no day off.... (That part is very inhuman. ) This is very depends of the maid, as i knew and hear the case, most of maid day off they will:
* do special servcesi with man
* steal our money to pass her freinds to keep it.

Honestly if you ask me,, i think one month one day off is accetable. By the way, employee maid is for LUCK no matter the maid b4 was working which country.

GOOD LUCK TO ME AND EVERYONE FIND A GOOD MAID.!!!!!


大宅

積分: 2422


16#
發表於 11-4-12 14:23 |只看該作者
回覆 MAMA-BEANBEAN 的帖子

Yes, this year increase so much . That why most of INdo maid likes to going to HK to working. IN SG hard to find Indo maid right now.

I m using 2 months to find . still cant.... Finally i choose 賓賓! Wish everything OK for me


翡翠宮

積分: 82477

畀面勳章 環保接龍勳章


17#
發表於 11-4-12 14:29 |只看該作者
回覆 星星國媽媽 的帖子

hey~
For the HDB part, cos i lived in HDB back then, and know that all HDB doesn't have maids room designed in it. (liked I said, I don't know if the design has changed. But the brand new flat that my sister is getting next year is still without maid's room, so I don't think there is much change on that)

and most of my singaporean friends have all the rooms occupied by family. so a lot of them have the helper sleeping in the kitchen (with curtains covered).

Sorry if I made it sound bad.. But i have to say, yes, the apartments are much bigger, and the kitchen is also much bigger... and so there is more than enough room for the helper to sleep in the kitchen. I don't think that is actually bad.

As for the pt about no day off.. .I still think it is inhuman for someone to have to work all year round with no rest day. Even just 1 day a month is too little. I don't think that is acceptable.


As for the point about most of them are using the day off to service man and pass the stolen money to friends (??) I believe there are people who will do that, but you can't say most of them will do that. As for stealing, I don't think it matters if she has day off or no day off, if she is gonna steal, she will.




大宅

積分: 2422


18#
發表於 11-4-12 15:15 |只看該作者
Oh, 大家討論下姐, 唔sorry
Ok, 據我知和見過: Yishan, Serangoon north, Jurong East 係有一間細少工人房的. 可能我身边朋友個個,親戚和我都沒有叫工人訓廚房啦.,

至於放假她們所做的事,我們無法控制,我相信係香港都有可能發生這種事. 而且她們明知到SG 工作而沒有假期,她們都接受 then OK LA.
再者現在好多到跑到去HK工作, 她們已經知道外面薪金和福利.所以無人迫她們.
至於:人權.我只可以說: 處處鄉村,處處例而已.

點評

gemiling  Yishan, Serangoon north, Jurong East... I know that for the very old HDB flats they have a storage room... that can be used.. but the newer one (i stayed in bedok) doesn't have it..  發表於 11-4-12 15:29
gemiling  my sis is at seng kang .. but no maid room...  發表於 11-4-12 15:28


大宅

積分: 2422


19#
發表於 11-4-12 15:16 |只看該作者
咁你個工人 ok ma?


翡翠宮

積分: 82477

畀面勳章 環保接龍勳章


20#
發表於 11-4-12 15:26 |只看該作者
回覆 星星國媽媽 的帖子

ask you asking me if my helper is ok? :D I am in HK ah! and I am one of the few lucky one that has a really good helper.

I also heard from her that actually it is easier to apply for visa to singapore becos of the ASEAN countries regulation.. that's why a lot of them went to singapore. Cos it is easier to get there to start with.

But of cos, after knowing other places have better pay, they wanna leave sg to go else where...

首頁
12

尾頁

跳至
Presslogic Logo
Baby Kingdom Logo