我唔贊成體罰, now, my son is 4.5 years old, I never hit him, if he is really naughty, I will bring him to the bedroom and tell him what he was wrong. Furthermore, I'm not allow him to play anything until he calmed down. I think that this is a great punishment for 4 years old kid.
我贊成適當既體罰,但係有時覺得心痛,我對囡囡由小到大都有體罰。
我大嫂同我相反,唔主張體罰,佢個女而家兩歲幾,我(只係本人)覺得佢唔聽話,食飽嘢周圍跳,我亞嫂(佢媽咪)不停咁叫佢唔好跳佢都唔聽,我亞嫂淨係識講,"唔準跳呀!再跳我就打你架喇!"呢句嘢,可惜一次都無打過,佢個女就不停咁out of control,我覺得咁樣無阻嚇性,而且我亞嫂一唔順佢個女既意願,佢就用喊嚟迫使佢亞媽就範。
我唔敢話自己好識教女,但係如果我講咗兩次唔準跳,再唔聽話我會立即打,唔會再有警告,所以我囡囡都算係幾聽話,我話唔得個D嘢佢都會停。