Just read thru all of the comments, so useful. Btw, just wanna share i actually think the HR eye cream in golden box (not the green packing) is really good. I went to bbq in winter time and sat so close to the fire. Both my eye bags got dried up first and then cracked. I was looked like an 80 yrs old lady. I went to see dermatologist but he said nothing can help but waiting for self recovery. I wanted to cry that time. Eye bags started peeling and i started applying the HR cream. i found my fine lines existed before bbq even got cured. So i don't think if some JM said the eye cream not working is this the same as mine or the one in green packing?!