吹水玩樂

時事理財

由家出發

媽媽天地

育兒教養

情報分享

意見反饋

聯絡管理員

我的中心

Baby Kingdom - 親子王國香港討論區 › 首頁 › 大仔大女媽媽會› 彥媽與你:BB 讀書/學習交流站 (答問區) ~~ Part 2 ...

大仔大女媽媽會今日: 0|主題: 177861

收藏本版

發帖

返回列表

跳至頁

樓主: 彥彥媽咪

[2006年] 彥媽與你:BB 讀書/學習交流站 (答問區) ~~ Part 2 [複製鏈接]

11 121314 15...58

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

241^#

發表於 07-10-23 17:25 |只看該作者

Dear all

彥媽放左個悠長假期呀....hehe...very relaxing...好...依家即追番d Q&A , 即答番先...

cherry_bb:
1.)想問有關學之園 & Victoria 之分別?因為學之園D家學校太新.
==> Habitat 唔算新了, 都有好幾間分校 in HK 的, 只係 Victoria 較佢有名所以你有此印象吧.....

大家都係以英語教學掛歲, 同 HK Preschool (樂基) 都係個類喇...問題係 Victoria 係行 IB course, 即國際學校條路, 仲有埋小學中學配套, 學之園就冇, so 睇你想要邊樣咁啦...

本人比較喜歡雙語學校.
2.)請問學之園好D 定係 THINK INT'L?
==> 同級既野, 好似比較緊 BMW 同 Benz 咁, 真係各有所長既, 真係好難話邊個好過邊個, 所謂"好" 好多時係家長 preference only, 因為大家 offer 既野, 同辦學模式都相近.

3.) KLN CITY OR KLN TONG 還有邊間有雙語學校
==> Shamshuipo 祟真有國際班, 而另外好多 at Kowloon Tong 個d都一定有埋 English + PTH ga la...只係唔係話去到乜都用 PTH 咁既 je....so should also fit your need.

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

242^#

發表於 07-10-23 17:32 |只看該作者

tokkibb:

我想請教下我本人係 St. Paul's Covent school(Causeway Bay)嗰間幼稚園到中學畢業生。我個女係家中大女,

1,如果我想佢入讀該小學,係咪kindergarten就要入,因為佢小學收哂大部份佢既幼稚園graduates, and
==>St Paul Convent 係直資, 即係佢想收咩人係佢話事, 唔到阿公管, so according to their policy right now, 佢地係先收哂自己 nursery 個d, then 就 KG 個 d 先既, so of course 讀佢地 nursery + KG 既係會有著數的

If 到小學先去考佢都得, 不過就 super 難啦, 因為佢超多 old girls la...所以 old girls 對佢地黎講唔多有優勢, 我有 friend 佢都係好似你咁由細讀到大, 但都係唔收佢個女, so 要入就要由 nursery/KG 入手, unless 你有 super good network with the school la...

2,如果入唔到kindergarten,小學係唔係跟政府個统一派位呢?
==> already answer you above...

3,請問ST. Paul's宜家係屬於邊一類?直資 or DSS?
==> 你冇溫書...

DSS = Direct Subsidy School , 咪即係直資囉....喂..你咁問係咪要打呀~~

[ 本文章最後由彥彥媽咪於 07-10-23 17:35 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

243^#

發表於 07-10-23 23:18 |只看該作者

fish_ball:

想請教你對以下學校有什麼評價?

(1) 救世軍田家炳
(2) 聖心

==> 兩間都係地區名校, 聖心...按有家長讀過既所講, 學校較傳統, 但之所以咁多年都係 hot school , 亦自有其過人之處, 故都係好多家長既首選

田家炳所知不多, 但救世軍搞既幼兒教育亦有唔錯既口碑, 若唔介意佢地唔似聖心咁有聯繫小學 or 中學 like 聖心, 所以有d家長唔揀佢 as first choice 咁啦...

[ 本文章最後由彥彥媽咪於 07-10-23 23:19 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

244^#

發表於 07-10-23 23:40 |只看該作者

miumiuchu:

我而家十五十六, 好想聽下你的分析。我現家住荃灣, 心水小學有兩間, a) 天神嘉諾撒 b) 聖羅撒。事實上a是我的小學母校, b是我的中學母校, 加上小女已經領洗, 所以如我替她1st round選a, 她有25分, 從我理解, 應該好大機會中。但是小六後天神的學生要和St Mary’s 小學的爭中學學位, 機會會減半, 自己三姊妹都是天神小學畢業, 都是只有大家姐可以入到St Mary’s 中學, 所以我知道話就話天神同St Mary’s 結龍, 但係唔safe。另一方面如果我替小女選b, 她只有20分 (獨女), 但我記得你答過一個媽咪話如果St Rose 20分都ok, 而入得St Rose 我都預左佢上埋中學, 咁我地將來壓力會小好多。而且聽講小女入小學之時新校舍又ready, 學校環境會好好多。不過齋比排名, 又好似St Mary高好多, 咁唔知彥媽你有何高見?

==> 我會有幾個 comment here:

(1) 一條龍既 definition 係中學係會有足夠既學位去收哂佢d 小學生 (if 達標), 因此, even St Mary 中學既可以同兩間小學去結龍既話, 咁就即係代表佢地中學會有足夠既學位去 accommodate 哂 all P6 graduates, so 呢點我唔太擔心...除非阿女唔爭氣, 成績太差喇...以前會有機會考唔返上中學係因為佢地係"直屬" before, i.e. 只可以收 max not more than 85% of P6 graduates, so 有人派唔番一d都唔奇, 但依家結得龍就要包收, 唔同的.....so ..相對地..

(2) I believe you also know..中學既收生機制唔同小學, 係以學生成績黎論英雄, 因此 even you St Rose 係有中學, but 佢地係直屬 only, 亦要係 2013 年以前就 confirm 結龍 or 轉 DSS , otherwise 就要同小學脫勾, 唔可以優先收佢小學既學生, 雖然我有理由相信學校都一定會係限期前結龍 or change to DSS 去保留"直升"呢個關係, 而以依家未結龍既關係係直屬黎講, 就都係要以成績論英雄, so if 阿女成績唔夠既話, 都唔一定可以升得番 ga ja wor...so I can't see 佢升中既 risk 可以細得過 St Mary 幾多, 而且話哂後者係結左龍, 要包收的, right?

(3) 你自己都知, St Mary 係全港 22 間傳統名校之一, 有多年 success history, banding of course 係高過 St Rose 喇...so in view of the fact 我自己有 background (舊生有分), St Rose 又唔係最高 banding + 包升中學 (at least at this stage) 咁我睇唔到 why 有更好既學校同背景去考而唔去, 反而去一間唔見得升中風險會細好多既學校.

(4) 再者, if St Rose 結龍, 多數要轉 DSS , 咁就同 St Mary 唔同, 即係要收費, so maybe this will be another concern...反而係要諗, under 阿公咁派位法 (世襲 + 抽獎) 既話, 佢地學生既質素是否仲可以維持高水準先係最 affect my choice 既 major concern...因為 if St Rose 可以有自行收生既權利 (DSS) 咁就又唔同咁講了.

[ 本文章最後由彥彥媽咪於 07-10-24 00:07 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

245^#

發表於 07-10-23 23:54 |只看該作者

mamay:

For the following 5 primary school, how will you rank the ranking?

1. St. Paul Boys
2. 港大同學會
3. 高主教
4. St. Joseph
5. 英華

若單以學術成績, 收生水準計.....St Jo 最突出, 無他, 競爭大, 汰弱留強下, 讀得上去既一定係勁.....

之後既...St Paul Boys 算係 2nd la....英華可以排 3rd (因為依家轉番 DSS) ... 高主教近幾年大不如前, so 我會放 4th...

HKUGA 係新校, 未有往績可以睇, 我依家唯一睇到既係佢地既人事, 制度, 各樣都年年可以唔同, 所有承諾過既野都會變既....因此, 我對佢有保留, 要睇定d先可以再有新評估, so 現階段我會排佢 5th~~

仲有...見你列得出呢幾間, 你個 kid 係仔, right? seems 你 prefer 單性學校??? and, just FYI...你知唔知依家高主教收埋女仔架喇..??

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

246^#

發表於 07-10-24 00:05 |只看該作者

supergirl:

睇咗你既大作但好似無咩人問過你德雅幼稚園及德雅小學, 可唔可以比d意見!
==> 因為德雅係一間幾普通既學校, 冇乜特別賣點, so 就冇乜人提 gum la...

咁同聖母, 禮賢,宣道等相比又如何呢?
==> 你想點比, 有得直升?? 係既話, 佢地呢幾間都有...不過大部份家長一定會將德雅放在呢幾間之後 (if 有得揀) 就係咁....

還有迦南同york2間幼稚園, 邊間好d呢? york 好重英文,但迦南收學劵,會唔會因此而有很大差別呢?
==> 兩間都係商營學校, 佢地係好 "customer oriented" 的, 因此一定做d 家長鍾意既野比你地, 唔會差好遠, 呢點你又可以放心, 問題只係在於商營 KG 因冇財團 back up (like those 有宗教背景呀咁個d ) 因此佢地既營運資金好倚賴學費收入, so 越收得多學生佢地既 cash flow 就會越好, 先會越對學生有保障, so if 收生唔足, I guess 你都可以想像諗下佢地可以點經營間學校了.

聖羅撒都係考慮之一, 但怕校舍擴建唔知會唔會塵土飛揚呢??-(
==> 我選校係以學校既 course curriculum , teacher's quality, 學生係d咩人 etc 為 higher priorities 的, 間學校響邊, 校舍新定舊, 有冇塵土飛揚唔係我既 top concern , 所以我唔多理的. 因為呢d問題我有 N 個方法可以補救, 但間學校d 料同人唔得就乜都補唔到, 所以你呢個問題在我黎講 weighting 唔高.

私人傳訊

supergirl

大宅

積分: 1717

247^#

發表於 07-10-24 17:50 |只看該作者

彥媽,

唔該晒! 呢幾日睇到d chat講又一村幼稚園, 佢地好似地大物博, 不過課程好似話好淺, 唔知有幾真, 請問彥媽有無咩comment咁呢? or 你會覺得same as創價呢一類唸

thanks again

p/s: 去咗邊樹旅行? 同埋3 個小彥

真開心!:mrgreen:

私人傳訊

miumiuchu

複式洋房

積分: 481

248^#

發表於 07-10-24 18:25 |只看該作者

唔該哂彥媽，你真係好勁，（jhfjgklgd4e03woeiprdjgikg）小女都要同你say thank you呢！

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

249^#

發表於 07-10-25 11:00 |只看該作者

supergirl:

呢幾日睇到d chat講又一村幼稚園, 佢地好似地大物博, 不過課程好似話好淺, 唔知有幾真, 請問彥媽有無咩comment咁呢?
==>又一村係好多年的了, 但佢俾人既印象就係好似你有既一樣喇...咪就係地大物搏呢樣令人記得佢啦, other than this, 佢冇乜野俾人留意到的...so if "地方大"係你選校首要條件, then it will fit you.

or 你會覺得same as創價呢一類
==> 創價新過又一村....d人鍾意因為話佢學到既野多, 佢同劍鳴算係同一類既野啦.

p/s: 去咗邊樹旅行? 同埋3 個小彥

真開心!
==> 梗係只同老公去先會最開心架喇...hehe...

:lol

私人傳訊

禁止訪問

積分: 1172

250^#

發表於 07-10-26 16:40 |只看該作者

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

私人傳訊

Heid

洋房

積分: 37

251^#

發表於 07-10-27 23:26 |只看該作者

Hi 彥媽,

I am a new comer to this topic. Please bear with me as I don't know how to type Chiness, so I can only use cut and paste. In addition, my English is not very good so hope you understand my question.

My girl is 0407, and I am living in Hunghom (net 35). I have some question below:-

1) From the 精華篇, it seems we should target a primary school or even secondary school then decided which KG?

2) How about the secondary school? If we choose a primary school which doesn't has 一條龍中學 then?

3)I am the old girl of 馬頭涌官小(PM), so should be the one now called 馬頭涌 (Hunghom Bay)? My girl has 20 marks (10 for old girls and 10 for 1st child) and should have a good chance? How about the comment of this school?

3) I am a bit worry as in my days at (many years ago!

) there are many famous and good secondary school to choose but now it seems not the case. Since most of them like Maryknoll, St. Mary, La Salle and DBS are switch to DSS / private so they don't have extra space for other primary school student to apply? Also the 伊利沙伯中學 will cease the relationship with 馬頭涌 after 2012? Please revert if my understanding is not correct.

4) I browsed the EMB web and found out there is very few school to choose in net 35 :-( !How about the other primary school like: 聖公會奉基千禧小學 or 聖公會奉基小學 or 天神嘉諾撒學校

They seems very similar except one have connected with St. Mary.

5) My hubby's primary school has already disappear and it is not easy for us to move. Finally, we may need to go for the DSS/private school.

6) Do you have any comment for 啟思中學 or Victoria Secondary?

Thanks a lot for your help

私人傳訊

babyj

別墅

積分: 956

252^#

發表於 07-10-28 02:18 |只看該作者

彦媽,

我想幫囡囡報playgroup, 等佢可以同小朋友玩下, just for fun!而家有兩個choices:
1. 用廣東話(母語)的, 但位置比較遠
2. 用英語的, 但位置比較近
我係prefer 2 的, 因為近.

我想問下, 如果報讀英文playgroup, 會唔會影響囡囡學習母語呢? 唔該晒!

私人傳訊

culver

大宅

積分: 1293

253^#

發表於 07-10-28 15:40 |只看該作者

彥媽,

I have a question/ comment here. See if I get the concept correct or not?

A lot of parents are very eager to send their kids to 傳統名小學 such as La Salle, Maryknoll etc. in the hope that the kids can get into the through train 一條龍中學. If this hope is in vain after their "Mark 6" lucky draw, it's like a matter of life or death.

However, , isn't there another chance after 6 years when they can try through the 中學自行分配學位? From my understanding, even for 一條龍中學, they need to reserve a small number of places for govt. At that time, "以學生成績黎論英雄". So if these parents are so determined to send the kids to all these famous secondary schools, they should be able to do somethings within these 6 years, right?

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

254^#

發表於 07-10-29 10:31 |只看該作者

yf:

唉....最近右8多左間:mrgreen: 大圍孫方中你點睇呢? 佢係全普通話教學.
==> 地區 hot school, 積極提升緊自己

如果要排, (1) 聖心 (2)田家炳 (3)吳多泰 (4)孫方中 , 你會點排法呢?
==> 呢幾間都係地區 hot school , 比我排, 我較 pro (1)+(2), then 就到 (3) 之後 (4)

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

255^#

發表於 07-10-29 10:59 |只看該作者

Heid:

In addition, my English is not very good so hope you understand my question.

==> 呵呵....打唔到中文字唔係問題, 唔溫書就黎問d重覆性既問題先係問題...

1) From the 精華篇, it seems we should target a primary school or even secondary school then decided which KG?
==> 若你係 target DSS or private school 就要既, otherwise 邊間幼稚園 not a big deal under the govt allocation system.

2) How about the secondary school? If we choose a primary school which doesn't has 一條龍中學 then?
==> 唔多明你想問乜 here, 冇一條龍都冇問題架, 家長要揀一條龍係唔想煩 only la...but if the kid 成績係得既, 考 band 1 中學係冇問題的. 你 continue to revise 精華篇 + 答問篇丫...我入面有講升中派位機制的.

3)I am the old girl of 馬頭涌官小(PM), so should be the one now called 馬頭涌 (Hunghom Bay)? My girl has 20 marks (10 for old girls and 10 for 1st child) and should have a good chance? How about the comment of this school?
==> 係, 你有得 20 there chance 就好高, 因為呢間學校冇教會背景, 就少左班人鬥分數, 呢間都係 hot school , 不過一向口碑上係舊校好d.

3) I am a bit worry as in my days at (many years ago!

) there are many famous and good secondary school to choose but now it seems not the case. Since most of them like Maryknoll, St. Mary, La Salle and DBS are switch to DSS / private so they don't have extra space for other primary school student to apply?
==> 係, 因為呢d好學校唔想受阿公既干預, 想自己收番佢地想收既學生, 所以呢類學校轉哂 DSS, 依家只係天主教個幾間因為教會唔俾轉, 所以未轉而已 (La Salle, Maryknoll, etc) 但相信佢地受既壓力會越來越大, 轉埋 DSS 相信都係遲早既事.

仲有, 你唔好搞亂住, 依家 La Salle, Maryknoll 呢d 只係 "直屬關係" , 佢地未 announce 轉做一條龍的, 而 so far 傳統名校中只有 St Mary 係津貼一條龍, 英華今年都轉埋 DSS 既一條龍啦, so you have to understand 直屬既 definition 係可以收 not more than 85% of 佢直屬小學既學生 only, so 成績上都要鬥一鬥, 同一條龍唔同, 一條龍係"包收"的 (不過都有d basic requirement , e.g. 考試及格就得), 而每間一條龍既學校除左要有足夠學額收佢小學學生外, 仲要有唔少於 10% 既學額供外來生投考的.
(喂...你要溫書 here wor....我以前有講過的

)

Also the 伊利沙伯中學 will cease the relationship with 馬頭涌 after 2012? Please revert if my understanding is not correct.
==> 基本上唔止你以上講呢幾間啦, 所有個d 中學依家同佢小學有直屬, or 聯繫關係既, 都要響 2013 (唔係 2012, 阿公早前 extend 左多一年寬限期) 前 announce 結唔結龍, 結就好似我上面講, 要 prepare enough 學額 to take over 所有佢自己既 P6 學生 + allow 10% 位比外人考, 但因為有d學校礙於地方問題, 資源問題係唔一定可以做到的, 因此係咁的話, 結唔到龍又好, 唔想結龍又好, 就 all 要 2013 後解除本來直屬 or 聯繫關係, 變成冇關係, so most likely La Salle 呀, 呢類會結龍, 而官小同官中就會關係脫勾

你講既伊利沙伯中學同馬官不嬲都係聯繫關係 only, 本來都係只可以收 max 25% 學生 of 佢聯繫網既 P6 students ga la...亦唔係只收馬官既學生, so 即係唔係多啦.... so 話時話, 脫左都唔係太大影響了, 反而佢真係結龍就有 jetso 喇.

4) I browsed the EMB web and found out there is very few school to choose in net 35 :-( !How about the other primary school like: 聖公會奉基千禧小學 or 聖公會奉基小學 or 天神嘉諾撒學校

They seems very similar except one have connected with St. Mary.
==> 天神嘉諾撒學校 is hot becos 佢同 St Mary is 一條龍丫嘛...other school 一般啦...overall speaking, net 34 is better than 35 的.

6) Do you have any comment for 啟思中學 or Victoria Secondary?
==>呢兩間我又係答左 N 次.....唉....:cry: 見你新黎, 又俾一次 chance 你, Creative 係活動教學, 同 Victoria 一樣都係行 IB, so it depends on 你 buy 唔 buy IB syllabus la...

For more details...要請你 go back 慢慢溫書啦...

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

256^#

發表於 07-10-29 11:02 |只看該作者

babyj:

我想幫囡囡報playgroup, 等佢可以同小朋友玩下, just for fun!而家有兩個choices:
1. 用廣東話(母語)的, 但位置比較遠
2. 用英語的, 但位置比較近
我係prefer 2 的, 因為近.

我想問下, 如果報讀英文playgroup, 會唔會影響囡囡學習母語呢? 唔該晒!

==> I dun think so, unless 你第時講英文多過廣東話啦...

私人傳訊

彥彥媽咪

子爵府

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

257^#

發表於 07-10-29 11:06 |只看該作者

culver:

彥媽,

A lot of parents are very eager to send their kids to 傳統名小學 such as La Salle, Maryknoll etc. in the hope that the kids can get into the through train 一條龍中學. If this hope is in vain after their "Mark 6" lucky draw, it's like a matter of life or death.

However, , isn't there another chance after 6 years when they can try through the 中學自行分配學位? From my understanding, even for 一條龍中學, they need to reserve a small number of places for govt. At that time, "以學生成績黎論英雄". So if these parents are so determined to send the kids to all these famous secondary schools, they should be able to do somethings within these 6 years, right?

==> 你講得岩, 係可以到中學再考佢, 不過....嘿嘿, 駛乜等到考中學咁耐丫....基本上只要小朋友係有特異功能既話, starting from P2 已經會同佢年年搏插班喇...因為一定有少量位的 (e.g. P2 後有d人會走的, e.g. 去外國升學, 揾到更好既 etc)