我當日開呢個 topic (仲好多謝版主幫我"置頂"等各位易揾嚟睇) 就係知有好多你呢類新手媽咪 here, 因為久唔久就會有人問 e.g. XX 幼稚園好唔好, DWE 買唔買得過, 考小學係咪要由揀幼稚園開始, etc.....我之前都打過唔少 reply, 真係唔想再打 N 次, 而且有好多野唔係三言兩語就可以令你明 why I suggest in this way, 我講野唔係要人跟我 decision, 而係要明白 why I make such decision, 呢點好重要, 因為係好在乎大家理念是否一致, so 我唔係太喜歡有d人問, e.g. XX KG 好唔好...then 有d人一句就話: "好呀, 我阿仔話番得好開心"...then 結論就係 XX KG 係"好好"了...
我就唔認為係, 因為好...係好響邊先...? so 咁同人講佢唔係太好既"幫助", 俾我我會講埋我揀佢因為, for example, 有連繫小學, 有足夠戶外空間, etc....咁人地先會明, 原來個間我 suggest 個間幼稚園係因為有此兩項條件我先揀佢既, etc...
This is very important , 因為 if 家長係唔太介意有冇得直升, or 空間大唔大 etc, then that XX KG 自唔會叫做"好"喇...right?
So 我一向只喜歡講 "facts", then buy 唔 buy 就各人按各人 priority + preference 去決定, so finally 人人都唔會"後悔" that decision 就係皆大歡喜了... :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
<<呢個 topic 我 stop 住先, 彥媽都有野想講 about this, but later sin la..>>
先回應吓你d questions:
所以就諗不如選St.Joseph可能會大機會D,
貪佢一條蟲,校風都算OK,位又多D.
==> Let me update 你:
(1) St Joseph 話會響 2008 學年將其小學同中學結龍, 但唔會轉 DSS, 仍維持津貼, 但因要結龍 (即係要 ensure all P6 students can promote to F1) 依家佢地 F1 好似得 5 班 ga ja wor...而小學就 8 classes, competition 相當"血肉模糊" (唔見 almost 一半 ga), 第日要結龍即係小學唔可以多過 5 classes, 仲好似想轉埋 whole day class...then 點會仲"位多d", 佢 if 真係轉 (轉就轉硬 ga la...係幾時轉 la...I guess 2008 may be a bit too hurry, 2009 la...but 點都好, 都我地d 2006 BB 去就 should change to 一條龍 ga la)
(2) 校風都算OK
==> 呢句我同意 in a way 你要知佢係一間極傳統既學校, 即係都幾著重學術, 要學生乖乖守規個停, otherwise 實收 complaint 電話收到你暈, 功課亦唔少, 屬"谷"個種, so 好唔好好睇家長要求同適應力了
(3) 位又多D
==> 上面講過...唔一定...都係抽 la...又係天主教徒個d會多 5 分 la (same as 番禺華仁), 佢幼稚園係由 K2 開始 , 但唔係 guarantee 直升 (因小學係津貼, so 一定要抽), 不過按以往 record 睇, 因為佢小一有八班, so can save some places for KGs kids to enter in the 3rd round la...但為配合將來結龍後都可以令 KG 生 to enter at 3rd round, 佢地今個學年已大幅少收 KG 生 (around 80 only) 咁.....你話 N 人考 80 個位可唔可以話"位多"丫....尤其 if 有仔個d家長知可以搏 3rd round 入埋 St Jo 小學就可順利上埋中學, 咁更一定多人喇....so I would say chance 面同考華仁一樣咁難....
想請問下選D有名氣或深D的K1
會5會對於考入去會有影響,易入D呢?
==> 唔會有太大分別, 只要唔係去d真係字都唔教多隻個d 就會 OK la...but of course K1 都深個d 去考起碼小朋友都識多d野咁喇....at least 到時會肯同識答問題 gum la....但我睇要考到入去, 反而係要睇個小朋友是否係斯文淡定, 受得苦 (要追得好快), 受得壓, 又要上堂乖乖定定個停反而會有 jetso...因為人地既教學模式就係咁....擺明係"傳統過唔傳統既教學", so 好唔好就因人而異喇...
定有他野可以預備下呢?麻煩哂!!!
==> 操吓佢d 英文 at K1 la....因為 St Joseph 英語水平相當高吓....but this can be done not only at KGs la..可以入 K1 之後俾佢去吓d English classes la...could help too.
==>
(1) 唔係....呢樣係冇 100% 既, 坊間夠有人教點計點計就會生仔 or 生女喇...呵呵...咪一樣有人求仔得女...
(2) 咁樣填唔係入到"派到心水第一志願小學"就高d, 而係因為 Part A 若你填哂三間, then according to the system , 派唔到 1st choice 比你就會順派 2nd choice, then 3rd choice 先再到 Part B, so if 你真係"非君不嫁"的話, then 填完 Part A 1st choice 之後唔填, system 就會再 scan 你 Part B, so if your 1st choice in Part B 都係同一間學校, then 即係多一個機會去派咁喇...但都要睇人地係唔係個個都響 Part A 填此校做 choice ma...因為 system 係先派完 Part A 先派 Part B ge...因此, 唔可以話"派到機會大D", 而係"叫個 system 快d睇你個 Part B, 搏佢早d 輪到派你個 Part B, 咁又或者有機" gum lor...
咁第二欄[第二志願]"技巧"又點填好, a)冇咁熱門學校, 入到機會高? b) 按心水band 1學校順序排列?
==> 嗱...詳細既你到小朋友 K3 先再去聽喇..唔駛咁快知住既, 因為你會好快唔記得既...hehe...不過你想知, 就 tell you a 大概先喇...
(1) 你要先好清楚 (a) 係咪只去某一間, 其他個d 派到都唔會去讀 or (b) 都會考慮 other choice
(2) If you prefer (a), 咁 very simple, just fill that one school and that's fine...no matter Part A or B
(3) If you are (b), then you have to fill in your choices according to your preferences la..不過小心既係, 唔好將d hot school 由 1- 30 咁款去排, this is a total waste, 因為兩間 top schools as 1st and 2nd choice, system 係先按所有人既 1st choice 派, 派唔到就 screen 2nd choice, etc etc, so if you put e.g. 協恩 as 1st choice, then St Rose as 2nd choice, 咁 2nd choice 多數/一定派唔到, 因為有好多人同時會以 St Rose 做 1st choice, so 個班人就會得位先喇....明此 principle or not?
So that means, 1st choice 可以搏d, 去大家鬥抽籤, 但 2nd choice 就要行穩陣將, 即係 either 次一線既學校, so even 2nd choice 都派得入, or 間學校超多位, so 2nd choice 都輪到有位, etc.
你打去問佢課程係咪淺d 咪即係 = 打去百佳問"我聽人話你地d product quality 唔係太高 ga , true or not?" 一樣 ==> 你想人地點答?...你想人話:"係呀...我d野係渣d架" 咁呀....???? 傻妹....
全 HK 人 (including the schools) 都知十個有九個家長都唔 likey 課程淺 ga la...你仲咁問人...我係佢都話唔係喇...傻既...
你再睇清楚我之前 explain nursery vs. KGs la....幼兒園本來就係以 total different system 去 run, 同 KG 唔同, 前者以"全人"為 focus, so 乜都有, e.g.自理 + 學術兼備, 但後者就係專為學術而設, focus 都唔同, 我話佢淺都係 quote 大部份人家長既心態喇...你知喇...始終好多家長都係鍾意 "快人一步, 著著領先" ga ma....咁見到自己小朋友 N2 個時仲係劃緊線, 但人地 K1 就開始寫到"屋"字咁...去到 N4 仲係數數, 人地 K3 就已雙位加數, then 你話d家長會唔會叫個d 做"淺"丫...但既然讀得到 N4 都一樣可以派位, then it's up to the parent to decide 想"先甜後苦" or "先苦後甜"囉 (註: 因為好多小學一上小一就要學雙位加數 etc ga la...so if 你個仔 6 月之前仲淨係數1-100 , 但9 月之後要你計條加數出嚟我睇你暈唔暈 )
另...再補充.....救世軍一樣有搞幼稚園既....that means just offer K1 - K3, 你問個間樂民唔係 K1-K3, 係 N1-N4, so N2 話就話 = K1, but somehow 間間學校d K1 都唔一樣喇...何況 N2 同 K1?
私小係比留位又比去搞珠, 搞得唔好, 又可以番轉頭讀
==> 我冇一個 full list, but so far I know 好似祟真, 禮賢呢d 得, 民生, 培正個d 都唔得, 你去考個時可以問埋學校先決定嘛....而且, 話時話....到你個時你就唔會理架喇..只要間私小係靠得住, 你都會去搏吓先 ga la...
類似 course 基督教服務處 (HKCS) 都有搞 (叫"幼兒潛能發展課程")...但佢地就 6 mths 起都搞...well...我一向唔太讚成太早就去上呢d course, 起碼識行識走去上都話...6 mths...嘿.....真係坐都未穩....邊駛咁快上堂....當上嚟大家 for fun 既我都可以理解.......之不過 if for fun 我會較 prefer 間唔時帶佢去海洋公園 or 廸廸尼 etc....去呼吸下郊外空氣多過成堆人堆埋一齊響一個 a/c room 入面玩交叉感染....
But 你個 BB 依家 17 個月, 想俾佢見吓人呢點我都明既, then you may try 呢類 courses la...遲d HKCS 都有另一個叫"開心荳芽組", 呢個我知都幾好玩...好似係收 18-36 mths ge....但若我已俾 BB 返 N1 , then 我就唔會再 enrol 呢d喇...
) ...i.e. 先唔該由我呢個 topic Page 1 一路睇落去, 你依家十個有九個問題我都有答過架喇....
...俾你笑到我肚痛......!!
發表於 
返回列表
