siubakto 寫道:
Sandralo:
我想問若小朋友堅持指定某人做一些東西(如:幫他抺鼻涕),但當其他人做左,他便會大發脾氣,甚至打人。除左無做時讚他及平時講道理之外,當其他人做了,他打人我便罵他企,但到目前為止,情況都無改善,請問還可以點做呀 ??
請問在當時情況是否都不應遷就他,讓他有選擇權呢 ??
JigJig 寫道:
Sandralo:
我的兒子現在22個月,個性十分自我. 我叫他時他總是像聽不到,亦很小肯跟從我的指令去做. 不論你跟他說多小次,如果他不想做,即使是懂得/明白指令,也不會做. (e.g. when I say "touch your nose" he won't do it but when he hears his CD says the same thing, he will follow).
如果有D野他想要或想做, 但我吾比他做 (e.g. a dangeruous act such as pushing the speakers or he wants to watch DVD but he needs to go to sleep), and I say "NO" to him, he will 發脾氣, 大哭,要我抱,咬我, pull hair (mine and his). I have tried to ignore him, and put him down on the rubber mats and let him cry it out, but he would always run towards me and want me to hold him, and then if I hold him, he will bite me. The situation just gets completely out of hand. I have tried explaining to him that he should not bite and pull hair, and whenever he bites/ pulls my hair, I will put him down on the floor mat again. this picking up/ putting down and crying can last for an hour. So I am very tired in the end. Can you offer me some advice?
linglingy2k 寫道:
我一路都有同學校老師溝通,你既建議唔錯要佢做雙倍~!!不過d老師可能真係太多野做,佢地成日都好似唔係唔想幫,但係冇咁既時間去只係為你個小朋友做野咁,成日都係罰佢地企不過冇check佢地,佢地有冇去罰企都唔知,個囡返嚟周不時都有話我知有咁既情況~
我個囡佢好多時都唔會理後果,只係要當時既好處,佢明知唔做份功課會欠交,一樣要做返,仲要比我罰,老師又會罰佢罰抄,要做既打仲多左,但佢都唔會理,仍然係到時先算!!!最緊要依家唔使做,懶得就懶~!!(佢真係好懶架,懶到可以唔沖涼,唔刷牙洗面,唔整理自己d野,總之就咩都唔使做就最好)
SandraLo 寫道:
[quote]
JigJig 寫道:
Sandralo:
我的兒子現在22個月,個性十分自我. 我叫他時他總是像聽不到,亦很小肯跟從我的指令去做. 不論你跟他說多小次,如果他不想做,即使是懂得/明白指令,也不會做. (e.g. when I say "touch your nose" he won't do it but when he hears his CD says the same thing, he will follow).
如果有D野他想要或想做, 但我吾比他做 (e.g. a dangeruous act such as pushing the speakers or he wants to watch DVD but he needs to go to sleep), and I say "NO" to him, he will 發脾氣, 大哭,要我抱,咬我, pull hair (mine and his). I have tried to ignore him, and put him down on the rubber mats and let him cry it out, but he would always run towards me and want me to hold him, and then if I hold him, he will bite me. The situation just gets completely out of hand. I have tried explaining to him that he should not bite and pull hair, and whenever he bites/ pulls my hair, I will put him down on the floor mat again. this picking up/ putting down and crying can last for an hour. So I am very tired in the end. Can you offer me some advice?
be_be 寫道:
Hi SandraLo,
十分多謝你解答我們的難題. 現麻煩你可否抽一點時間, 看一看我囡囡的問題, 謝謝.
我囡囡現在兩歲, 她從少到大都很乖, 很聽話. 以前我和老公早上出門口上班, 她會跟我們攬攬和kiss的.
但在五月開始, 因我想看看她可否適應在九月返上午班nursery, 所以我幫她轉了返上午的playgroup. 所以, 我現在一星期有三天會跟囡囡和工人一起出門口, 一同搭車返學. 頭兩天都好好的, 我預先告訴她姐姐會跟她先下車, 一同回學校玩, 媽媽放工再回家跟她玩. 她都很開心跟我說再見.
但之後的日子, 她一認出快要下車的地方, 她便緊緊的攬著我, 不停叫媽咪, 很怕我離開她似的. 在她和姐姐到站下車時, 更大哭起來. 她真的很少哭得那麼可憐.
另外, 在前天早上, 她不用上學 , 但她早起了. 當我離開家去上班時, 我就像以往一樣跟她說再見, 但她不讓我離開, 更哭得腰都往後’ao’, 我便跟她說媽媽放工就回來, 和其他安撫的說話,她都只是不停說’no’和攬實我. 我唯有請姐姐帶她入房, 分散她注意, 之後趁機離開. 我回到公司再call姐姐, 姐姐說囡囡出到廳之後看不見我, 都沒有哭, 她還告訴姐姐’mami is going to work’.
我現有以下問題, 真的想向你請教一下.
(1)我不知我有否做錯….因她在家哭不想我去上班, 我有去抱她, 叫她不要哭, 和跟她說理. 這會令她下次再哭得更嚴重嗎?
(2)我最後用’趁機離開’, 好像不太好?
(3)我怎樣處理和她一起搭車上學? 我可以做些什麼可讓她和我開開心心說再見呢?
(4)暫時囡囡在其他所有時候都很乖, 但很擔心她會慢慢的變得naughty呀.
Thank you very much.
JigJig 寫道:
Many thanks for your prompt response and I will certainly try the "praise" method which I have not used before.
I have tried using the baby cot but it gets dangerous as he will cimb out of the cot (an act which he is capable of doing) and I also worry about him developing negative associations with his cot as he is already difficult to put down to sleep.
You suggested leaving him with the helper when he is out of control. Can I understand the reason behind that ?
If he still bites or pulls hair (whether myself or the maid), how should I handle it? If my maid is holding him and I see he is about to pull hair, I will hold his hand and tell him firmly that he should not pull hair. however, usually he is already in such a state of anger and distress that he cannot pay attention to what I am saying.
I also have to confess that my so called "ignoring" method is a bit of a hlaf-baked cake cos I can never sustain, this is what happens usually:-
1. Son is insistent about sth (e.g. wants to watch DVD) and I said "No".
2. Upons realising that I do not follow what he wants, son throws tantrum and cries loudly and then pull me towards DVD player and I said "No" again.
3. I will then ignore him by pretending to read a magazine whilst he sits on the floor and cries, or he will bang on things and yell loudly and cry to express to anger. After crying for about 2 min he will come towards me and snatch my magazine from my hand and want me to hold him (he is still crying).
[I have tried two ways to handle this]
A.) I have tried holding him and explaining to him what is wrong. He usually just cries even louder like he is out of control and then he will bite me on my shoulder whilst I am holding him. At this point I will put him on the mat and tell him that if he bites, I have to put him down. this usually repeats (i.e. hold him > he bites> put him down > he calms down a little and stopped crying > I pick him up > he cries again> he bites > I put him down again......)
B.) the alternative method I have tried is I will continue ignoring him and will walk away from him. he will then chase me and try to pull me down because he wants me to hold him. This usually makes him feel even more angry and, I think, rejected. and he will keep running towards me wanting me to hold him (this struggling between us can last for a long time) and in the meantime i keep telling him that he has to stop crying before Mummy holds him - he usually just gets more and more out of control and inconsolable, and he will be chasing and following me around the living room.
Be it method A or B, either situation will last for an hour or so as my son appears to be more out of control and crying just for the sake of crying it out and he will also pull his own hair. In the end I just cave in and pick him up and hold him (he may still bite but by this time he is usally exhausted from the 1 hour saga and it is easier to restrian him). After I have picked him up I will say things to calm him down. I will take this time to tell him that I understand he is agry but that he cannot always wtach DVD all the time and it is wrong to bite.
he will usually still cry and sob for another 10/15 minutes. Sometimes he will (baby) talk like he is complaining to me (and I will talk with him too repeating that Mummy understands he is angry and mummy was trying to help him). He may either calm down completely or he will want to start crying again. if the latter I will give him something to distract him (e.g. toy) as I am also completely exhausted by that time and I cannot deal with another saga.
he usually will behave better (i.e. less easy to throw tantrum) for some time (e.g. couple of weeks) after this saga and I dunno whether he learnt that this crying business is not worth the while or whether the crying provided a channel for him to let out his energy and furstruations.
I ot not sure what I am doing is right (my gut feeling tells me that it is not) but in any case I am just getting quite sick and tired of this sort of battle with my son, and feel helpless about the situation.
Could you please let me know your views?
many thanks in advance for your advice.
be_be 寫道:
SandraLo,
十分多謝你的回覆. 我已將你的回覆跟老公分享了, 他都十分認同你的做法, 我們會跟著去嘗試. 我今早已嘗試很開心的和囡囡說再見, 今晚要讚讚她呢.
我老公有另一個問題想請教, 又要麻煩你了.
我老公很錫囡囡, 有時候, 他對囡囡的愛心和耐性比我對囡囡更強. 他每天放工或假日, 都會陪她玩, 但不知為何囡囡好像有時會刻意冷落daddy或表現出不喜歡daddy.
好像昨晚, 我跟囡囡在房中對著電腦看照片, 當daddy入房時她便叫她daddy出去, 不想他join我們.
之後, 她拿了數本相簿入房看, 自己手拿一本看, daddy想拿另一本和她一起看, 但她卻不肯跟daddy一起看, 所有都要自己keep起. Daddy又’tum’又傾, 但她都無反應, 他於是扮嬲, 背向囡囡坐. (這只會發生在daddy身上, 囡囡會讓我和工人姐姐看) 囡囡見daddy這樣, 就拿相簿去跟daddy說東說西, 想'tum'番daddy一起看.
囡囡很多時都只會喜歡跟我玩, 跟我一起, 只想kiss我, 攬我. 但有時她又會跟daddy好friend, 所以我們不知怎麼辦好.
我想問以下問題:
(1) 我跟daddy都不明天為何囡囡有時會抗拒daddy? 是因為daddy太熱情?
(2) Daddy扮嬲是一個好的做法嗎? 我們是否應在她做得好時, 大讚特讚? 除此之外, 我們還可怎樣做?
真的十分謝謝你為我解答問題.
mdoip 寫道:
Hi Sandralo ,
又有問題請教了! 之前bb打人, 向你請教後 , 在我們多番讚賞後 , 已很少出現這情況! 但最近跟bb老師傾談後 , 加上自己的觀察 , 仍然有很多問題向您請教 !
bb現時約二歲半 , 返了幼兒班約半年 , 老師說他不專心 , 如塗顏色不會望著幅畫來塗 ; 玩桌上玩具經常換 , 而老師覺得應選定一樣來玩 ; 而且玩得好顛 , 如唱歌跳舞時十分興奮 , 或是跑不停!其實老師所講的亦符合我的觀察 , 經常叫唔停 , 特別是制止他的不當行為 , 有時帶他到公園玩 , 他都會十分興奮 , 特別是同其他小朋友或他喜歡的人一齊玩的時侯!
請問 : 1. 如何改善不專心的情況? 2. 如何令他叫得聽?
謝謝!!
mdoip 寫道:
Hi SandraLo,
多謝回覆
点樣「叫唔停」法呢?
例 : - 叫佢不能掂風扇 , 不能琴桌椅 , 通常佢都唔會理我們!
- 喜歡在街上留連 , 很難叫佢跟著行!
- 到遊樂場玩時不肯走 , 如果只有我和他一起去時 ,不會出現不肯走的情況 , 我會同佢講好 , 又提佢 , 又叫佢同遊樂場say goodbye , 基本上算合作 ; 但一和佢喜歡的姐姐和叔叔一起去時 , 情況就很難控制 , 結果要捉佢走 , 有點不歡而散!
- 老師說佢在學校玩得很顛 , 玩車時及跑得很快 , 很忘形 , 要叫住佢 , 驚佢撞倒其他小朋友!
他喜歡的事可以做多久?
20-30分鐘
謝謝!!