:-P :-P :-Psamantha821 寫道:
1.FA8866-支持,希望快D取消或者減低每月$200蚊外傭稅.
2. 巴士阿叔
3. Superfish
4. Jaime
5. virgokaren (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
6. sako
7. sammili
8. 佘媽
9. mcdull
10. bobosweet (取消400蚊外傭稅 )
11. MavisNg...舉腳贊成
12. SandyHung
13. 子峰mama
14. Christy-mama
15. appleapple2006
16. Ansonbb
17. luiling
18. 淑筠媽咪 (最好refund之前交左既比返我地)
19. 小B媽咪 (如果政府肯,都好過咩都無.因為要政府取消外傭稅,我諗難過登天!不過現在外傭薪酬實在太高了，我自己都無一千蚊零錢比自己洗)
20. kk1706
21. lawandrew
22. Allie
23. zipzip(不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
24. bobo
25. mylulu007 (唔駛交$400就真)
26. Y123
27. cw-kk
28. Happy&Happy (其實請一個外庸=?多一位小朋友, 對小康之家來說, 真係好重負擔架.)
29. yin2002(我幾年都冇人工加!!!)
30. blythe
31. 高鈴 (取消$400/月 LEVY)
32. mamamia (淨係記得對外傭要公平, 甘對我地d中產又唔見對公平d, 你估我地好歎, 特別請個工人來享受, 其實係做埋搵埋都唔夠, 唔覺意請左個垃圾返來, 仲想死)
33. mickeywinnie3
34. 姑姑
35. mymelody2003
36. DoReMi媽媽
37. markbean
38. Kandl
39. hehalady
40. blythe
41. Paulchen1
42. rainbowshiu
43. cheukcheuk(支持取消外傭稅!
44. 1357
45. 3littlepigs
46. rubyhappy2
47. 開門見山(請特首體恤民意為衣歸,保障外傭僱主)
48. Barbara
49. mocha
50. BO_BO
51. HongCheong [?解只係同傭人唸,唔同?我?返工一族唸.唔通本地工人會減價?]
52. E&J
53.jurlique (要求減收外傭稅, 要增加外傭試用期, 取消最低工資, 由市場自行調節)
(攪番個遊行比我地班可憐僱主申怨)
54. karen8888
55. 2jmama
56. winny
57. J&D (可以取消就最好啦, 就算減半都照殺, 仲有請求, 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票就ok)
58.Lemon7831
59.rrrr
60.Fionyiu
61. Hellodaddy + 太太 (係時候檢討外傭政策!)
62.abbytang
63.yellow
64. jennysky
65.QQ2003
66. cat_house
67.kc2021 (養個工人, 要用幾多錢呀? 生/養/教一個小朋友又要幾多錢呀 ? 現時政府重話鼓勵我地生多幾個, 邊個支持我地, 工人有問題, 僱主要補足比佢地走, 小朋友有問題, 家長又要付責任. 我們一一都知道, 但希望政府能夠明白我地, 唔減外傭稅, 不如比個外傭稅免稅額我地, 大家話好唔好)
68. ckckcktina
69. Krymum
70.purplebbbb
71.KWANWAILIN
72.雪瑩媽咪 (我都覺得我地做左boss既責任,應該俾番個外傭免稅額我地)
73.HeiShun_Mum
74.emilylisa
75.Matt_Matt
76.心遂
77.jaycie
78. Charlotteling
79. Auntie-DOS
80.焯嵐媽咪
81.summer_66
82.Fireman
83.Kinki_ma
84.Jacqueline_law
85Hoiyingw
86. 小草
87. steffany
88. CW-KK
89.bbkingdom
90.winnie_sh (外傭嘈完話要番$400就加$80...咁依家輪到僱主要求政府減外傭稅，否則呢次廿幾萬僱主要走出黎，睇黎政府都會好頭痛，快D派糖俾番D僱主順番條氣)
91. twinsmama
92. sylvia wong
93.sunnyman
94. talkative
95. EmilyBB
96. MAXIMS ($2000/月 就合理)
97.catcatmom
98.Jacqueline310
99.KaKaYa
100. meowmi
101. B珠Mummy
102. sylviawu
103. 芝達（唔知點解要幫外傭訂定最低工資，本地工人就冇呢個福利？其實你畀二千，個工人肯做，又關政府乜事呢？）
104. lui_BB
105. phoebemama
106.BB頭maimimi (如果鼓勵生育,就唔該幫下手節省家庭開支啦!)
107. tteresa (其實我既收入已經剛好比左工人同自己既車費, 但怕自己照顧bb將來找唔番野做, now想生多過都唔敢怕到時又話要加人工比佢地, 我已經幾年無加人工啦)
108. sanlap (係咪要我O地生三個先? 如果係, 曾生你的外傭政策同你要求相遺背喎!)
109.bkmummy
(政府又想我?生多d, 但係又唔諗?個個多數都係
因為冇人湊先至要請外傭, 並唔係因為我?有好多
錢而請佢?, 政府提供兒女免稅額又小, 仲有學費
減免條件大部份人都享受唔倒, 政府真係應該好好
諗d方案.
以我自己家庭為例 : 家庭每月收入2萬, 供樓8仟,
工人薪金+外傭稅+insurance4仟, 兩個女現同時
入讀幼稚園4仟(享受唔倒學費減免), 剩下的便時
家庭開支, 根本入不敷支, 我相信有很多家庭ㄕp
我一樣, 政府你們真的應該為我們這些家庭諗?.)
110. ks
111. meifun
112. willin
113. Opheliamama
114. Dorothy
115. ksma
116. 靚媽媽
117. haileymama
118. 肥仔媽咪 (你話外傭稅用來交俾政府都算啦, 但用來補貼再陪訓局)
119. appleapple2006
120. kfwong---(請外庸只不過為湊小朋友,並不是我地好有錢, 而家工人的人工比起其他國家高好好多。)
121.appleyuen
122.Joann
123. Sephina
124. 貝貝
125.wwc
126. dolphin (應該取消交$400至得)
127.Sammiy (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
128.edentiffany
129.Coco926
130.conniengor
131.Sabinamama (救救政府比條生路我地一班中產人士吧. 我今期要交成相等於2個月人工的稅. 家陣又話要加工人人工....放過我啦....救命呀)
132.kilna
133.芷殷
134.nami-nami
135.WINNIEYIP
136. winkylee (支持要取消400蚊外傭稅 , 取消加薪,上年先加完, 今年又加, 天理何在!!)
137.pearlinamok
138. kookamfai
139. puifun
140. sa_mama
141. bellalp (佢?d外傭做得唔好, 炒佢又要補; 我?唔係有錢人呀, 請佢?都係為世所逼, 為?份工咋 !!)
142. babycancan
143.天MO豬媽咪
144. magicmirror
145.傻鴨菇芝
146.busymami
147. bby (佢地仲好福利過我老公喇 )
148.Peggyst
149. 瘋口組
150. PrinceWong
151. Isis_Iain
152. Ada_pang (不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
153. kwankit
154. cc&longlong
155. shalie (特首鼓勵我地生3個,但係又比吾到實質支持,我地係出面做餐c,都無人工加,反而個工人加完$50又$80...我地d苦況,特首究竟了解幾多?我地除左出糧比工人,又食又住又保險(好多時claim吾足),開支真係好大,子女駛費又多,返左工又驚工人對bb吾好,我地d壓力可真不少.....)
156. 布甸仔媽媽 (而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670, 係咪有問題ar )
157.甜芋
158. joyce & roy
159.Cheachea
160.chistybbmama
161.Josephine
162. rchu01
163. alalma
164. kachunma
165. littlebirdbird
166. prettymama
167. moomin10
168. Melody1234
169. bb-lam
170. Hviy
171.emilychoy
172.ntkwong
173. carmenyip
174. Whitesnow
175. chumama05 (去年加一次, 今年又加, 但d稅又唔減, 我地又冇人工架, 小朋友學費又咁貴, 咁我地d打工仔點挨呀, 係咪要轉行羅綜援)
176. esmehouse
177. rosannaching重有可吾可以不給工人一個月工資 同回程機票?因為工人偷我地野,重要比錢佢好吾公平
178. Fayme
179. ManLam
180. ChloeMak舉晒腳讚誠減收外傭徵稅, 咁快又加, 想我?死咩, Total 成$3800+日常起居飲食, 加加埋成４千幾, 點頂呀! 政府?然今年賺咁多稅,不如分返Ｄ比我?啦, 200蚊都好呀!
181. jessieoh - 本地工人都無最低工資, 點解香港政府唔protect香港人架?
182. Yvonnehon -- 政府成日手指咬出唔咬入, 我?香港人都無最低工資啦, 點解又唔立例喎!
183.SILVIA......快D取消外僱稅啦......唔該!
184.烏龍媽咪
185. mandywan00..我仲未加人工喎！
186. carolyktong...咪係，我都無人工加，點解要加比佢喎！
187.Karson ma
188. Jenny1234…支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收, because 而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670.
And 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票!!!
189. longlongb
190. tungtungma814 仲加
191. vnice (1.現今請外傭已經不是為"奢侈"的生活享受,絕大部份家庭都只為照顧小孩或老人家,實在是無可奈何之策.2.請外傭的家庭並不代表"富裕",相反都是中產階層,政府要提高外傭薪金,無論加多少,對聘有外傭家庭實在是一個長遠負擔 3.政府稅收充裕,毋須在中產開刀,令大家百上加斤 4.政府徵收外傭稅,美其名為"培訓",徵收以來,未見有實質行動,外傭質素亦未見提高,相反外傭虐待幼兒的新聞屢見不鮮,請再檢討是否有收外傭稅之必要! 5. 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,工積金又要供,薪酬增幅未能同步,亦不足以抵銷開支上的增加,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!)
192. anitapooh--淨賺！包食包住包醫療，不用交通不用靚衫！
193.CKMA (取消$400外傭稅)
194. Hkbuffet
195. gegemok. 我覺得所有野應該由市場定價,為什麼要有最低工資呢? 為什麼政府要攪亂自由市場?如果佢地真係值咁多錢,我地比得少,佢地都唔來啦!!??香港人都未有最低工資? 請問香港政府 d 錢由那裡來, 為什麼手指"咬"出,唔"咬"入,支持減收外傭稅~~又或者支付外傭的費用可減薪俸稅.
196. qqmom (Yes, 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,薪酬不增幅,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!100% agree. ) Actually if the people hire more than one maid in hong kong then they have to pay the extra fee to government but not from us.)
197. Tinnie (可以取消就最好啦, 外傭應該有三個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票 香港工人都有試用期, 點解外傭放假一樣,試用期不同....)
198. 哪哪 (政府完全不需要咨詢任何意見,就加外傭人工,但是大部份人的工資就沒有加過。外傭工資就在一年內左右加了兩次，這樣做變相加重僱主負責。根本很多僱主的工資都不是很高.政府這樣做會造成更加多的婦女要放棄自己的工作,而選擇在家照顧自己的小朋友.)
199. Cookie99 (I haven't expense more than $1000 a month for my personal belongings and leisure expenses)
200. Mrs.Chan(請體恤民間疾苦)
201. Betty媽咪 (請工人是無可奈何, 2個小朋友無人看管, 加外傭人工都算, 但400元徵稅實在太重, 頂唔順. 自己咁多年都冇人工加, 希望政府派粒糖比我地, 無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫唔該!)
202.Stella.yam(要加都應該以經驗黎加,唔係話加就加)
203.sausauma
204.LydiaWong
205.henrymama (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 外傭加薪又是用咩標準, 有無咨詢過? 是否太過隻手遮天, 妄顧香港人的利益?)
206. doristsang
207. lui_ho ((香港打工仔邊有咁幸福...有最低工資+兼老細交埋稅+唔駛俾千蚊租屋供樓?!?!?!發夢!!! 我自己一個月都冇三千幾蚊零用呀!!!!!))
208. luluma (傭稅減半, 支持到底, 又再加薪, 僱主加辛)
209. ronleung
210. samwin
211.瑤瑤媽媽
212.Noddy-mammy(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
213. pandafong (不如開放內地既保母市場啦,有競爭先有進步呀)
214.jacquesl(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
215. CINDYC
216. smilesun
217. JCLEE
218. 225333 (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 到而家都仲涷緊薪!即使私人公司都唔係真係咁好境啦!點解外傭可以加完咁快又加???外傭加薪係用咩標準, 有無咨詢過?強烈要求爭取傭主在申報薪俸稅中可扣除外傭薪金的支出!
219. Blakema
220. FK (no consultation stage, only govt say then get money from our pockets. Foreign domestic helpers have no probation period, got 100% medical coverage, they don't have to pay transportation, rent & rates, food, water, gas and electricity. Govt claimed that all DHs came to HK with at least 2 years experience, how our govt guarantee their working experiences are true and suitable for their employers. We heard foreign DHs ill-treat children from time-to-time but I have no choice to let a stranger to take care of my little children because I must go out to work to maintain my family.
Companies, organisations - salaries and benefits for employees are tax deductible, why we have to pay tax, foreign DHs enjoy lot of benefits (any body here <BK> enjoy 100% medical coverage?) but as employers, we cannot claim tax deduction?
I strongly believe many employers of foreign DHs are not rich. Like me, we believe in a small flat, my DH has to share a room with my CHILDREN. Our govt should not impose too many restrictions on foreign DHs policies. We do not have minimum salary, why they have? I trust that it should depends on the market rate. If they think our offer is low and not attractive, they can choose not to come.
Interest for mortgage has been increase few times this year, prices for food, medical, school fee, interest classes +++++. On holidays, many DHs just bring food from their employers home. Their living standard are higher than some of their employers. At least we only stay at home or go to the garden nearby during holiday because transportation fare is quite expensive particularly for a whole family.
Can all the messages here reach our Chief Executive Donald Tsang and get a fair response?
221. Babyjerry
222. BabyHazel~無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫
223.sharonli210
224.羊媽咪
225. Greenrainbow
226. 一家三口
227.櫻桃小貓子
228. conyyan 頂力支持
229. 富安開心媽-四個月內慘遭兩女傭玩謝;菲姐一個月不習慣香港生活,補多一個月錢加機票送她走,換印姐前又補4個月徵款先,她做了3個月走路,果3個月無得退,而家未揀新工人,好慘,所以支持減徵款,同時抗議唔聲唔聲又加合約人工.
230.citadel -外傭僱主才是真正的香港人，為香港的繁榮進步默默作出貢獻（給老闆剝削）！若果特區政府未能採取適當的措施保障外傭僱主的合理和合法權益，受影響的便是我們的下一代！有權就必有責，試想像外傭質素持續下降的當兒，不對「違法亂紀」的外傭加強懲處，就如多次涉嫌犯下虐兒、欺詐、行騙、盜竊等罪行的外傭竟然可以因證據不足而逍遙法外，仍可以一再申請來港工作的！這樣又怎會有人敢再來響應特首生三個小孩的呼籲（來承擔未來供養老化人口的重擔）！亦會令外傭僱主有後顧之憂，勢將削弱香港的生產力，特區政府不可不察！
231.KRISTINE 頂力支持
232.nonno123支持
233.veronica1210
234. Charis支持
235 Swimming
1. 無民意，有無同我地班顧主商量 (我地才係俾錢個個)
2. 政府話要保障本地工人，我地LEVY照交，但個衰工人走?，我地又有什麼保障
3. 我地返工都要自己安排交通費，佢地一個唔該，"我唔做" (有d根本就係自由行，今日到你屋企，發覺唔係一個五星級的家，明天便要你送佢返去)，便要我地買埋機票送到佢地返屋企門口
4. 要請工人的家庭，相信大多也是經濟需要兩公婆外出工作
236. LumLum (點解香港打工仔冇最低工資, 但外傭就有呢d保障????)
237.winnie lau
238.sinkiukiu
239.Brandanmama 頂力支持!!!
240.espirt
241.必必 - 外傭來香港打工, 食, 住唔駛錢, 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買田買地, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 自己身為香港居民都無此保障. 真係天埋何在?
政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意, 另仲要交外傭稅, 政府真係以為香港經濟好好, 但係有好多人幾年都無人工加過啦!
242.文卓媽媽-kat 支持支持 取消$400外傭稅, 政府有訓練過你或我個外傭嗎 ? 點解無人知道 ?
243. Joeystar: 支持支持支持支持
245. Christine
246. 快樂Ah咪
247. littlepig (政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意及尊重我們有交稅的"香港人")
248.??同意完全同意唔洗交或減收外傭徵稅
249.terecyy
250. Wendy518-Sum Sum 咪
251. joenam-I've written to Labour Department and copied to the major political parties to express our objection to the increment of minimum allowable wage for foreign domestic helpers.
252. Beryl 88318
253.Woodyryan(我都五年無人工加反而減左兩次，特首大人你有無了解清楚我地有幾困迫，外傭條例已經偏袒勞方，仲要再唔合理地增加最低工資，實在離譜啦！特首大人！請收回承命！造褔百姓！積福積德！
254.jasmine&lun-支持,支持,因養多個工人實在太重皮
255.魚子(比條生路行?啦... )
256.misslee一家
257.pandacat_bb (成日話鼓勵生育, 有冇諗過我?開支有幾大, 我?唔係?綜援, 唔係話生多個, 有多份錢, 樣樣靠自己架咋, 人地日本同法國都比生育獎金啦, 減下稅當幫忙都好呀
258.guy-完完全全應同減收外傭稅，政付應加以體諒我口地在職媽咪！
259. Carmen2004一家
260.915sooky我都好支持
261.FKWhat I feel very unfair for employers of foreign domestic helpers are that:
1. Govt treat us as normal employers, so our employers enjoy 100% benefits, even better than local employees, a typical example is 100% medical coverage, they do not have to pay 1 cent. Though DHs need to pass a medical check before they report duty but it won't check all, right? One of my maid before was admitted to hospital and did operation. I almost became mad during that period. Any boss can tolerate their staff to take leave often to take care of their children (it is merely a personal problem, remember companies are not charity organsation, we cannot ask our employers to be considerate.)
2. No probation period, even they work one day, we have to pay various fees and air tickets.
3. We have to pay tax because we employ foreign domestic helpers, can our government find some HK citizens to help us take care of our children from the time we go to work until we back home?
4. We are the one to pay salary and benefits but have no say in the terms, is it fair to us?
5. Normal employers can include employees' expenses, e.g. salaries, insurance for tax deduction, but we can't. We even have to pay additional tax.
There are few interest increases for mortgage, this already increase my economic burden, I found the prices of food are increasing from time to time, but any of those inflation related to foreign domestic helpers?
6. There are some cases that when foreign DHs maltreat children, their penalty is quite light. Many cases, like stealing, because of no evidence or employers do not want to get trouble and waste time, just terminate their maid but also need to pay one-month-in-lieu of notice. Any employers want to take risk to give a month notice?
7 I just want somebody to take care of my children so that I can go out to work to support my family. I do not get any subsidy from govt. But employ foreign DHs just like being penalised by our govt.
8 Our govt imposed too much restriction on the foreign DHs policy. Why she did not learn those good thing from Singaporean govt?
262. tpmak
263.mnlight73
264.Vanessa8 一家支持支持 取消$400外傭稅
265.咪落地
266.翁心怡, 外傭條例對顧主來說此乃不平等條約, 需急切從新修訂(包括減低外傭稅及降低最低工資)!!
267.gloria_sweet824 -yes, support!!
268. sinwin whole family
269. maysungsung
270. galslide
271. 3KidsMaMa (點解做工人會無試用期, 而有設有最低工資, 點解所有利益歸於工人, 特首呼籲港人生多幾個, 但又唔幫我?想?生完有幾多野要兼顧, 請個工人幫?手, 就反而沒有好處給僱主)
272. vhunghk
273. agnesmama
274. rainbowbb
275. yoballma 係啦, 其實請?個工人, 等於養多?一個人. 又包食, 又包住,所有?都預多一份, 根本同養多個人冇分別. 一闊三大呀.
276. snake (人工又唔見加好多, 樣樣都加價. 加左人工後還要倒貼)
277. charlotte_mom (唔減唔緊要, 唔該啦, 我地有時要中途轉工人, 已經身心疲倦+無奈, 又要賠錢送機票已經好慘, 唔該政府做下好心, 唔好再雪上加霜, 唔好再堅持"先炒舊人再批新人"至可以transfer levy喇, 我地個個都係為生計奔波, 唔"奢侈"得起請2個禮拜假去"替更"...
278. 肥媽咪
279.abby媽
280. yyvenus
281. DuncanMaMa
282. HOYIUMA - 請取消外傭稅, 負擔已經很大
283. cm93002 我地為?兩餐要返工搵錢先迫於無奈將個bb交比d十個有八個衰o既外傭湊，比錢之餘仲要擔驚受怕，
受佢地氣，真係心力交碎，精神衰弱，求下你地大發慈悲唔好樣樣o野都淨係保障晒佢地，我地做顧主o既就有苦自己知
284. yy2004 - 你地政府又話鼓勵我地生bb, 但另一方面又個埋呢d事去打擊我地, 請請你地細心去體會我地生活有幾辛苦...
285. Sweetsoul
286. JENNIFER
287. Feliciamama
288.zoe_tam
289.sesimo
290.corachan(人工無得加 , 邊個幫我地),請盡快取消外傭稅
291.winice-Support + agreed......! 簡直百上加斤呀!!
292. ysmhkg (大力支持)
293. holongmama
294. mandyyml
295. wc
296. yikmanmama
297. carolmama2005
298.yuiyuima 舉手支持
299. JojoB 全力支持
300.paulavincent It's not fair to us
301.PoohPooh123 - Fully support
302. yanyan0629 (除取消外傭徵稅外，我覺得未做滿三個月若被解僱便享有一個月代通知金簡直是不知所謂．勞工署要將外傭跟香港勞工看齊．勞工假，例假甚麼都一樣．為何我們本地勞工於大部分公司工作試用期頭三個月都只是一天或七天通知呢?仲有，政府收咁多$稅，唔該出visa就出快d,要我地等成兩個月先有工人到．比多d＄,工作效率仍不變，真的不合理！)
303. ronna1209--完全同意
304.chanrita1214-住力支持
305.martha.bb--d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;真係返??埋d$成3分1比佢仲要對佢地好d(驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路)........
306.angelalchansm-支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
307.mandicmy-fullly support (全力支持).政府都冇譜,淨?只諗外傭,唔使理我地?立稅人.錢就猛收
308. 卓衡父母
309. bebeyan, 應該減輕中產負擔. thanks !!
310.sidney-I have two babies, they are twins so I feel that is very expensive for me to employ two helper and need to give baby join playgroup.
311. Horlicks - 難為中產人士
312. joeyng--大力支持減輕中產負擔
313. hugo_ma -- 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買car買house,d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;仲要對佢地好好,驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 真係天埋何在? 我地人工又唔見加!
312. BonBon_the_pooh -- 舉手支持
313. florence0204 全力支持
314. blueglass--一年加2次正一特衰政府比董建x拾政時仲要衰100倍
315. mid-mid
316. coreymami
317.KWCHAN -我同老公兩個人搵錢, 又要供樓, 又要養父母, 舊年個仔出世, 無奈之下要請工人, 但人工冇加, 供樓利息加左, 開支大左, 每月支出仲多個收入, 點知仲要話加工人人工, 頂唔順之下炒左佢, 依家淨係亞媽照顧亞仔, 仲要煮埋飯比我地食, 佢老人家好辛苦, 我好心痛, 但冇辦法, 咁多把口要食, 咁樣點敢再生? 仲話生三個, 我驚比人話不孝播!
318. Kathy
319. godivachoc (唔取消?話, 就應該將依d外傭人工放埋入稅單到減稅!)
320. rm_cn (你估我們想要工人咩, 無辦法之嗎)
321. cmsfish( 我未有家傭, 因為手續繁複,錢銀多多, 法津保障佢?多過我?, 咁多錢請個人住在自己家中, 文化又唔同.真係好冒險, 問政府一句, 點敢生bb呀? 仲話呼籲巿民生多?. 教育又唔好, 請好既傭工又難, 而且又多錢, 點生呀?)
322. 嵐嵐媽咪(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)
323. ChunChunMame-Just like Canada, if you hire a baby sitter to take care of your child, we should get tax deduction as well. Furthemore, only for those we hire more than 1 maid need to pay the $400 tax as well.
324. skching 支持取消或減收外傭徵稅，政府應體恤下我地，唔係只僱住外傭，係亞洲地區佢
地人工都唔係低，我地都係因為生活先要請佢地揍小朋友.......
325. tamannabel (剛續了約人工加了$3400/續約費$3000/保險2年$770/政府稅半年$2400...暫時total:6170未計人工及機票) ...年尾又要交稅....好苦
326. Nattyma
327.chunbaby mama - 支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
328. p&c - 工人自己走.點知佢last day果日就係另一個月levy既starting date.所以冇無拿拿做多1日就咁比多$400.點解唔可以按比例扣返比下一個工人呢.
329.Shingshing&MaMa- 比左錢出去唔緊要, 但工人質素無保障, 作為消費者我地可以去邊度申訴?
330. RyanLeungmama
331. Mrs.Pretty Chan.Yes I agree
332.msllau(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)(年年人工減減減,外傭人工加加加;政府鼓勵生生生,家庭赤字升升升;如斯情況慘慘慘,特首可有想想想)
333.Patty (There should be one month probation! If they did not perform well, we could fire them immediately in the first month. We, HK workers, are submitted to various restrictions. How come Filipino maids have privileges???)
334. 臣媽
335. muicc
336. J&T&Family (一家大細都支持 取消$400外傭稅)!!
337. samantha821 - Fully support
peaceworld 寫道:
1.FA8866-支持,希望快D取消或者減低每月$200蚊外傭稅.
2. 巴士阿叔
3. Superfish
4. Jaime
5. virgokaren (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
6. sako
7. sammili
8. 佘媽
9. mcdull
10. bobosweet (取消400蚊外傭稅 )
11. MavisNg...舉腳贊成
12. SandyHung
13. 子峰mama
14. Christy-mama
15. appleapple2006
16. Ansonbb
17. luiling
18. 淑筠媽咪 (最好refund之前交左既比返我地)
19. 小B媽咪 (如果政府肯,都好過咩都無.因為要政府取消外傭稅,我諗難過登天!不過現在外傭薪酬實在太高了，我自己都無一千蚊零錢比自己洗)
20. kk1706
21. lawandrew
22. Allie
23. zipzip(不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
24. bobo
25. mylulu007 (唔駛交$400就真)
26. Y123
27. cw-kk
28. Happy&Happy (其實請一個外庸=?多一位小朋友, 對小康之家來說, 真係好重負擔架.)
29. yin2002(我幾年都冇人工加!!!)
30. blythe
31. 高鈴 (取消$400/月 LEVY)
32. mamamia (淨係記得對外傭要公平, 甘對我地d中產又唔見對公平d, 你估我地好歎, 特別請個工人來享受, 其實係做埋搵埋都唔夠, 唔覺意請左個垃圾返來, 仲想死)
33. mickeywinnie3
34. 姑姑
35. mymelody2003
36. DoReMi媽媽
37. markbean
38. Kandl
39. hehalady
40. blythe
41. Paulchen1
42. rainbowshiu
43. cheukcheuk(支持取消外傭稅!
44. 1357
45. 3littlepigs
46. rubyhappy2
47. 開門見山(請特首體恤民意為衣歸,保障外傭僱主)
48. Barbara
49. mocha
50. BO_BO
51. HongCheong [?解只係同傭人唸,唔同?我?返工一族唸.唔通本地工人會減價?]
52. E&J
53.jurlique (要求減收外傭稅, 要增加外傭試用期, 取消最低工資, 由市場自行調節)
(攪番個遊行比我地班可憐僱主申怨)
54. karen8888
55. 2jmama
56. winny
57. J&D (可以取消就最好啦, 就算減半都照殺, 仲有請求, 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票就ok)
58.Lemon7831
59.rrrr
60.Fionyiu
61. Hellodaddy + 太太 (係時候檢討外傭政策!)
62.abbytang
63.yellow
64. jennysky
65.QQ2003
66. cat_house
67.kc2021 (養個工人, 要用幾多錢呀? 生/養/教一個小朋友又要幾多錢呀 ? 現時政府重話鼓勵我地生多幾個, 邊個支持我地, 工人有問題, 僱主要補足比佢地走, 小朋友有問題, 家長又要付責任. 我們一一都知道, 但希望政府能夠明白我地, 唔減外傭稅, 不如比個外傭稅免稅額我地, 大家話好唔好)
68. ckckcktina
69. Krymum
70.purplebbbb
71.KWANWAILIN
72.雪瑩媽咪 (我都覺得我地做左boss既責任,應該俾番個外傭免稅額我地)
73.HeiShun_Mum
74.emilylisa
75.Matt_Matt
76.心遂
77.jaycie
78. Charlotteling
79. Auntie-DOS
80.焯嵐媽咪
81.summer_66
82.Fireman
83.Kinki_ma
84.Jacqueline_law
85Hoiyingw
86. 小草
87. steffany
88. CW-KK
89.bbkingdom
90.winnie_sh (外傭嘈完話要番$400就加$80...咁依家輪到僱主要求政府減外傭稅，否則呢次廿幾萬僱主要走出黎，睇黎政府都會好頭痛，快D派糖俾番D僱主順番條氣)
91. twinsmama
92. sylvia wong
93.sunnyman
94. talkative
95. EmilyBB
96. MAXIMS ($2000/月 就合理)
97.catcatmom
98.Jacqueline310
99.KaKaYa
100. meowmi
101. B珠Mummy
102. sylviawu
103. 芝達（唔知點解要幫外傭訂定最低工資，本地工人就冇呢個福利？其實你畀二千，個工人肯做，又關政府乜事呢？）
104. lui_BB
105. phoebemama
106.BB頭maimimi (如果鼓勵生育,就唔該幫下手節省家庭開支啦!)
107. tteresa (其實我既收入已經剛好比左工人同自己既車費, 但怕自己照顧bb將來找唔番野做, now想生多過都唔敢怕到時又話要加人工比佢地, 我已經幾年無加人工啦)
108. sanlap (係咪要我O地生三個先? 如果係, 曾生你的外傭政策同你要求相遺背喎!)
109.bkmummy
(政府又想我?生多d, 但係又唔諗?個個多數都係
因為冇人湊先至要請外傭, 並唔係因為我?有好多
錢而請佢?, 政府提供兒女免稅額又小, 仲有學費
減免條件大部份人都享受唔倒, 政府真係應該好好
諗d方案.
以我自己家庭為例 : 家庭每月收入2萬, 供樓8仟,
工人薪金+外傭稅+insurance4仟, 兩個女現同時
入讀幼稚園4仟(享受唔倒學費減免), 剩下的便時
家庭開支, 根本入不敷支, 我相信有很多家庭ㄕp
我一樣, 政府你們真的應該為我們這些家庭諗?.)
110. ks
111. meifun
112. willin
113. Opheliamama
114. Dorothy
115. ksma
116. 靚媽媽
117. haileymama
118. 肥仔媽咪 (你話外傭稅用來交俾政府都算啦, 但用來補貼再陪訓局)
119. appleapple2006
120. kfwong---(請外庸只不過為湊小朋友,並不是我地好有錢, 而家工人的人工比起其他國家高好好多。)
121.appleyuen
122.Joann
123. Sephina
124. 貝貝
125.wwc
126. dolphin (應該取消交$400至得)
127.Sammiy (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
128.edentiffany
129.Coco926
130.conniengor
131.Sabinamama (救救政府比條生路我地一班中產人士吧. 我今期要交成相等於2個月人工的稅. 家陣又話要加工人人工....放過我啦....救命呀)
132.kilna
133.芷殷
134.nami-nami
135.WINNIEYIP
136. winkylee (支持要取消400蚊外傭稅 , 取消加薪,上年先加完, 今年又加, 天理何在!!)
137.pearlinamok
138. kookamfai
139. puifun
140. sa_mama
141. bellalp (佢?d外傭做得唔好, 炒佢又要補; 我?唔係有錢人呀, 請佢?都係為世所逼, 為?份工咋 !!)
142. babycancan
143.天MO豬媽咪
144. magicmirror
145.傻鴨菇芝
146.busymami
147. bby (佢地仲好福利過我老公喇 )
148.Peggyst
149. 瘋口組
150. PrinceWong
151. Isis_Iain
152. Ada_pang (不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
153. kwankit
154. cc&longlong
155. shalie (特首鼓勵我地生3個,但係又比吾到實質支持,我地係出面做餐c,都無人工加,反而個工人加完$50又$80...我地d苦況,特首究竟了解幾多?我地除左出糧比工人,又食又住又保險(好多時claim吾足),開支真係好大,子女駛費又多,返左工又驚工人對bb吾好,我地d壓力可真不少.....)
156. 布甸仔媽媽 (而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670, 係咪有問題ar )
157.甜芋
158. joyce & roy
159.Cheachea
160.chistybbmama
161.Josephine
162. rchu01
163. alalma
164. kachunma
165. littlebirdbird
166. prettymama
167. moomin10
168. Melody1234
169. bb-lam
170. Hviy
171.emilychoy
172.ntkwong
173. carmenyip
174. Whitesnow
175. chumama05 (去年加一次, 今年又加, 但d稅又唔減, 我地又冇人工架, 小朋友學費又咁貴, 咁我地d打工仔點挨呀, 係咪要轉行羅綜援)
176. esmehouse
177. rosannaching重有可吾可以不給工人一個月工資 同回程機票?因為工人偷我地野,重要比錢佢好吾公平
178. Fayme
179. ManLam
180. ChloeMak舉晒腳讚誠減收外傭徵稅, 咁快又加, 想我?死咩, Total 成$3800+日常起居飲食, 加加埋成４千幾, 點頂呀! 政府?然今年賺咁多稅,不如分返Ｄ比我?啦, 200蚊都好呀!
181. jessieoh - 本地工人都無最低工資, 點解香港政府唔protect香港人架?
182. Yvonnehon -- 政府成日手指咬出唔咬入, 我?香港人都無最低工資啦, 點解又唔立例喎!
183.SILVIA......快D取消外僱稅啦......唔該!
184.烏龍媽咪
185. mandywan00..我仲未加人工喎！
186. carolyktong...咪係，我都無人工加，點解要加比佢喎！
187.Karson ma
188. Jenny1234…支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收, because 而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670.
And 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票!!!
189. longlongb
190. tungtungma814 仲加
191. vnice (1.現今請外傭已經不是為"奢侈"的生活享受,絕大部份家庭都只為照顧小孩或老人家,實在是無可奈何之策.2.請外傭的家庭並不代表"富裕",相反都是中產階層,政府要提高外傭薪金,無論加多少,對聘有外傭家庭實在是一個長遠負擔 3.政府稅收充裕,毋須在中產開刀,令大家百上加斤 4.政府徵收外傭稅,美其名為"培訓",徵收以來,未見有實質行動,外傭質素亦未見提高,相反外傭虐待幼兒的新聞屢見不鮮,請再檢討是否有收外傭稅之必要! 5. 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,工積金又要供,薪酬增幅未能同步,亦不足以抵銷開支上的增加,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!)
192. anitapooh--淨賺！包食包住包醫療，不用交通不用靚衫！
193.CKMA (取消$400外傭稅)
194. Hkbuffet
195. gegemok. 我覺得所有野應該由市場定價,為什麼要有最低工資呢? 為什麼政府要攪亂自由市場?如果佢地真係值咁多錢,我地比得少,佢地都唔來啦!!??香港人都未有最低工資? 請問香港政府 d 錢由那裡來, 為什麼手指"咬"出,唔"咬"入,支持減收外傭稅~~又或者支付外傭的費用可減薪俸稅.
196. qqmom (Yes, 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,薪酬不增幅,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!100% agree. ) Actually if the people hire more than one maid in hong kong then they have to pay the extra fee to government but not from us.)
197. Tinnie (可以取消就最好啦, 外傭應該有三個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票 香港工人都有試用期, 點解外傭放假一樣,試用期不同....)
198. 哪哪 (政府完全不需要咨詢任何意見,就加外傭人工,但是大部份人的工資就沒有加過。外傭工資就在一年內左右加了兩次，這樣做變相加重僱主負責。根本很多僱主的工資都不是很高.政府這樣做會造成更加多的婦女要放棄自己的工作,而選擇在家照顧自己的小朋友.)
199. Cookie99 (I haven't expense more than $1000 a month for my personal belongings and leisure expenses)
200. Mrs.Chan(請體恤民間疾苦)
201. Betty媽咪 (請工人是無可奈何, 2個小朋友無人看管, 加外傭人工都算, 但400元徵稅實在太重, 頂唔順. 自己咁多年都冇人工加, 希望政府派粒糖比我地, 無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫唔該!)
202.Stella.yam(要加都應該以經驗黎加,唔係話加就加)
203.sausauma
204.LydiaWong
205.henrymama (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 外傭加薪又是用咩標準, 有無咨詢過? 是否太過隻手遮天, 妄顧香港人的利益?)
206. doristsang
207. lui_ho ((香港打工仔邊有咁幸福...有最低工資+兼老細交埋稅+唔駛俾千蚊租屋供樓?!?!?!發夢!!! 我自己一個月都冇三千幾蚊零用呀!!!!!))
208. luluma (傭稅減半, 支持到底, 又再加薪, 僱主加辛)
209. ronleung
210. samwin
211.瑤瑤媽媽
212.Noddy-mammy(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
213. pandafong (不如開放內地既保母市場啦,有競爭先有進步呀)
214.jacquesl(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
215. CINDYC
216. smilesun
217. JCLEE
218. 225333 (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 到而家都仲涷緊薪!即使私人公司都唔係真係咁好境啦!點解外傭可以加完咁快又加???外傭加薪係用咩標準, 有無咨詢過?強烈要求爭取傭主在申報薪俸稅中可扣除外傭薪金的支出!
219. Blakema
220. FK (no consultation stage, only govt say then get money from our pockets. Foreign domestic helpers have no probation period, got 100% medical coverage, they don't have to pay transportation, rent & rates, food, water, gas and electricity. Govt claimed that all DHs came to HK with at least 2 years experience, how our govt guarantee their working experiences are true and suitable for their employers. We heard foreign DHs ill-treat children from time-to-time but I have no choice to let a stranger to take care of my little children because I must go out to work to maintain my family.
Companies, organisations - salaries and benefits for employees are tax deductible, why we have to pay tax, foreign DHs enjoy lot of benefits (any body here <BK> enjoy 100% medical coverage?) but as employers, we cannot claim tax deduction?
I strongly believe many employers of foreign DHs are not rich. Like me, we believe in a small flat, my DH has to share a room with my CHILDREN. Our govt should not impose too many restrictions on foreign DHs policies. We do not have minimum salary, why they have? I trust that it should depends on the market rate. If they think our offer is low and not attractive, they can choose not to come.
Interest for mortgage has been increase few times this year, prices for food, medical, school fee, interest classes +++++. On holidays, many DHs just bring food from their employers home. Their living standard are higher than some of their employers. At least we only stay at home or go to the garden nearby during holiday because transportation fare is quite expensive particularly for a whole family.
Can all the messages here reach our Chief Executive Donald Tsang and get a fair response?
221. Babyjerry
222. BabyHazel~無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫
223.sharonli210
224.羊媽咪
225. Greenrainbow
226. 一家三口
227.櫻桃小貓子
228. conyyan 頂力支持
229. 富安開心媽-四個月內慘遭兩女傭玩謝;菲姐一個月不習慣香港生活,補多一個月錢加機票送她走,換印姐前又補4個月徵款先,她做了3個月走路,果3個月無得退,而家未揀新工人,好慘,所以支持減徵款,同時抗議唔聲唔聲又加合約人工.
230.citadel -外傭僱主才是真正的香港人，為香港的繁榮進步默默作出貢獻（給老闆剝削）！若果特區政府未能採取適當的措施保障外傭僱主的合理和合法權益，受影響的便是我們的下一代！有權就必有責，試想像外傭質素持續下降的當兒，不對「違法亂紀」的外傭加強懲處，就如多次涉嫌犯下虐兒、欺詐、行騙、盜竊等罪行的外傭竟然可以因證據不足而逍遙法外，仍可以一再申請來港工作的！這樣又怎會有人敢再來響應特首生三個小孩的呼籲（來承擔未來供養老化人口的重擔）！亦會令外傭僱主有後顧之憂，勢將削弱香港的生產力，特區政府不可不察！
231.KRISTINE 頂力支持
232.nonno123支持
233.veronica1210
234. Charis支持
235 Swimming
1. 無民意，有無同我地班顧主商量 (我地才係俾錢個個)
2. 政府話要保障本地工人，我地LEVY照交，但個衰工人走?，我地又有什麼保障
3. 我地返工都要自己安排交通費，佢地一個唔該，"我唔做" (有d根本就係自由行，今日到你屋企，發覺唔係一個五星級的家，明天便要你送佢返去)，便要我地買埋機票送到佢地返屋企門口
4. 要請工人的家庭，相信大多也是經濟需要兩公婆外出工作
236. LumLum (點解香港打工仔冇最低工資, 但外傭就有呢d保障????)
237.winnie lau
238.sinkiukiu
239.Brandanmama 頂力支持!!!
240.espirt
241.必必 - 外傭來香港打工, 食, 住唔駛錢, 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買田買地, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 自己身為香港居民都無此保障. 真係天埋何在?
政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意, 另仲要交外傭稅, 政府真係以為香港經濟好好, 但係有好多人幾年都無人工加過啦!
242.文卓媽媽-kat 支持支持 取消$400外傭稅, 政府有訓練過你或我個外傭嗎 ? 點解無人知道 ?
243. Joeystar: 支持支持支持支持
245. Christine
246. 快樂Ah咪
247. littlepig (政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意及尊重我們有交稅的"香港人")
248.??同意完全同意唔洗交或減收外傭徵稅
249.terecyy
250. Wendy518-Sum Sum 咪
251. joenam-I've written to Labour Department and copied to the major political parties to express our objection to the increment of minimum allowable wage for foreign domestic helpers.
252. Beryl 88318
253.Woodyryan(我都五年無人工加反而減左兩次，特首大人你有無了解清楚我地有幾困迫，外傭條例已經偏袒勞方，仲要再唔合理地增加最低工資，實在離譜啦！特首大人！請收回承命！造褔百姓！積福積德！
254.jasmine&lun-支持,支持,因養多個工人實在太重皮
255.魚子(比條生路行?啦... )
256.misslee一家
257.pandacat_bb (成日話鼓勵生育, 有冇諗過我?開支有幾大, 我?唔係?綜援, 唔係話生多個, 有多份錢, 樣樣靠自己架咋, 人地日本同法國都比生育獎金啦, 減下稅當幫忙都好呀
258.guy-完完全全應同減收外傭稅，政付應加以體諒我口地在職媽咪！
259. Carmen2004一家
260.915sooky我都好支持
261.FKWhat I feel very unfair for employers of foreign domestic helpers are that:
1. Govt treat us as normal employers, so our employers enjoy 100% benefits, even better than local employees, a typical example is 100% medical coverage, they do not have to pay 1 cent. Though DHs need to pass a medical check before they report duty but it won't check all, right? One of my maid before was admitted to hospital and did operation. I almost became mad during that period. Any boss can tolerate their staff to take leave often to take care of their children (it is merely a personal problem, remember companies are not charity organsation, we cannot ask our employers to be considerate.)
2. No probation period, even they work one day, we have to pay various fees and air tickets.
3. We have to pay tax because we employ foreign domestic helpers, can our government find some HK citizens to help us take care of our children from the time we go to work until we back home?
4. We are the one to pay salary and benefits but have no say in the terms, is it fair to us?
5. Normal employers can include employees' expenses, e.g. salaries, insurance for tax deduction, but we can't. We even have to pay additional tax.
There are few interest increases for mortgage, this already increase my economic burden, I found the prices of food are increasing from time to time, but any of those inflation related to foreign domestic helpers?
6. There are some cases that when foreign DHs maltreat children, their penalty is quite light. Many cases, like stealing, because of no evidence or employers do not want to get trouble and waste time, just terminate their maid but also need to pay one-month-in-lieu of notice. Any employers want to take risk to give a month notice?
7 I just want somebody to take care of my children so that I can go out to work to support my family. I do not get any subsidy from govt. But employ foreign DHs just like being penalised by our govt.
8 Our govt imposed too much restriction on the foreign DHs policy. Why she did not learn those good thing from Singaporean govt?
262. tpmak
263.mnlight73
264.Vanessa8 一家支持支持 取消$400外傭稅
265.咪落地
266.翁心怡, 外傭條例對顧主來說此乃不平等條約, 需急切從新修訂(包括減低外傭稅及降低最低工資)!!
267.gloria_sweet824 -yes, support!!
268. sinwin whole family
269. maysungsung
270. galslide
271. 3KidsMaMa (點解做工人會無試用期, 而有設有最低工資, 點解所有利益歸於工人, 特首呼籲港人生多幾個, 但又唔幫我?想?生完有幾多野要兼顧, 請個工人幫?手, 就反而沒有好處給僱主)
272. vhunghk
273. agnesmama
274. rainbowbb
275. yoballma 係啦, 其實請?個工人, 等於養多?一個人. 又包食, 又包住,所有?都預多一份, 根本同養多個人冇分別. 一闊三大呀.
276. snake (人工又唔見加好多, 樣樣都加價. 加左人工後還要倒貼)
277. charlotte_mom (唔減唔緊要, 唔該啦, 我地有時要中途轉工人, 已經身心疲倦+無奈, 又要賠錢送機票已經好慘, 唔該政府做下好心, 唔好再雪上加霜, 唔好再堅持"先炒舊人再批新人"至可以transfer levy喇, 我地個個都係為生計奔波, 唔"奢侈"得起請2個禮拜假去"替更"...
278. 肥媽咪
279.abby媽
280. yyvenus
281. DuncanMaMa
282. HOYIUMA - 請取消外傭稅, 負擔已經很大
283. cm93002 我地為?兩餐要返工搵錢先迫於無奈將個bb交比d十個有八個衰o既外傭湊，比錢之餘仲要擔驚受怕，
受佢地氣，真係心力交碎，精神衰弱，求下你地大發慈悲唔好樣樣o野都淨係保障晒佢地，我地做顧主o既就有苦自己知
284. yy2004 - 你地政府又話鼓勵我地生bb, 但另一方面又個埋呢d事去打擊我地, 請請你地細心去體會我地生活有幾辛苦...
285. Sweetsoul
286. JENNIFER
287. Feliciamama
288.zoe_tam
289.sesimo
290.corachan(人工無得加 , 邊個幫我地),請盡快取消外傭稅
291.winice-Support + agreed......! 簡直百上加斤呀!!
292. ysmhkg (大力支持)
293. holongmama
294. mandyyml
295. wc
296. yikmanmama
297. carolmama2005
298.yuiyuima 舉手支持
299. JojoB 全力支持
300.paulavincent It's not fair to us
301.PoohPooh123 - Fully support
302. yanyan0629 (除取消外傭徵稅外，我覺得未做滿三個月若被解僱便享有一個月代通知金簡直是不知所謂．勞工署要將外傭跟香港勞工看齊．勞工假，例假甚麼都一樣．為何我們本地勞工於大部分公司工作試用期頭三個月都只是一天或七天通知呢?仲有，政府收咁多$稅，唔該出visa就出快d,要我地等成兩個月先有工人到．比多d＄,工作效率仍不變，真的不合理！)
303. ronna1209--完全同意
304.chanrita1214-住力支持
305.martha.bb--d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;真係返??埋d$成3分1比佢仲要對佢地好d(驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路)........
306.angelalchansm-支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
307.mandicmy-fullly support (全力支持).政府都冇譜,淨?只諗外傭,唔使理我地?立稅人.錢就猛收
308. 卓衡父母
309. bebeyan, 應該減輕中產負擔. thanks !!
310.sidney-I have two babies, they are twins so I feel that is very expensive for me to employ two helper and need to give baby join playgroup.
311. Horlicks - 難為中產人士
312. joeyng--大力支持減輕中產負擔
313. hugo_ma -- 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買car買house,d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;仲要對佢地好好,驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 真係天埋何在? 我地人工又唔見加!
312. BonBon_the_pooh -- 舉手支持
313. florence0204 全力支持
314. blueglass--一年加2次正一特衰政府比董建x拾政時仲要衰100倍
315. mid-mid
316. coreymami
317.KWCHAN -我同老公兩個人搵錢, 又要供樓, 又要養父母, 舊年個仔出世, 無奈之下要請工人, 但人工冇加, 供樓利息加左, 開支大左, 每月支出仲多個收入, 點知仲要話加工人人工, 頂唔順之下炒左佢, 依家淨係亞媽照顧亞仔, 仲要煮埋飯比我地食, 佢老人家好辛苦, 我好心痛, 但冇辦法, 咁多把口要食, 咁樣點敢再生? 仲話生三個, 我驚比人話不孝播!
318. Kathy
319. godivachoc (唔取消?話, 就應該將依d外傭人工放埋入稅單到減稅!)
320. rm_cn (你估我們想要工人咩, 無辦法之嗎)
321. cmsfish( 我未有家傭, 因為手續繁複,錢銀多多, 法津保障佢?多過我?, 咁多錢請個人住在自己家中, 文化又唔同.真係好冒險, 問政府一句, 點敢生bb呀? 仲話呼籲巿民生多?. 教育又唔好, 請好既傭工又難, 而且又多錢, 點生呀?)
322. 嵐嵐媽咪(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)
323. ChunChunMame-Just like Canada, if you hire a baby sitter to take care of your child, we should get tax deduction as well. Furthemore, only for those we hire more than 1 maid need to pay the $400 tax as well.
324. skching 支持取消或減收外傭徵稅，政府應體恤下我地，唔係只僱住外傭，係亞洲地區佢
地人工都唔係低，我地都係因為生活先要請佢地揍小朋友.......
325. tamannabel (剛續了約人工加了$3400/續約費$3000/保險2年$770/政府稅半年$2400...暫時total:6170未計人工及機票) ...年尾又要交稅....好苦
326. Nattyma
327.chunbaby mama - 支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
328. p&c - 工人自己走.點知佢last day果日就係另一個月levy既starting date.所以冇無拿拿做多1日就咁比多$400.點解唔可以按比例扣返比下一個工人呢.
329.Shingshing&MaMa- 比左錢出去唔緊要, 但工人質素無保障, 作為消費者我地可以去邊度申訴?
330. RyanLeungmama
331. Mrs.Pretty Chan.Yes I agree
332.msllau(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)(年年人工減減減,外傭人工加加加;政府鼓勵生生生,家庭赤字升升升;如斯情況慘慘慘,特首可有想想想)
333.Patty (There should be one month probation! If they did not perform well, we could fire them immediately in the first month. We, HK workers, are submitted to various restrictions. How come Filipino maids have privileges???)
334. 臣媽
335. muicc
336. J&T&Family (一家大細都支持 取消$400外傭稅)!!
337. samantha821 - Fully support
338. 珀珀,慧慧媽 支持
339. peaceworld
jhoyyhk 寫道:
[quote]
peaceworld 寫道:
1.FA8866-支持,希望快D取消或者減低每月$200蚊外傭稅.
2. 巴士阿叔
3. Superfish
4. Jaime
5. virgokaren (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
6. sako
7. sammili
8. 佘媽
9. mcdull
10. bobosweet (取消400蚊外傭稅 )
11. MavisNg...舉腳贊成
12. SandyHung
13. 子峰mama
14. Christy-mama
15. appleapple2006
16. Ansonbb
17. luiling
18. 淑筠媽咪 (最好refund之前交左既比返我地)
19. 小B媽咪 (如果政府肯,都好過咩都無.因為要政府取消外傭稅,我諗難過登天!不過現在外傭薪酬實在太高了，我自己都無一千蚊零錢比自己洗)
20. kk1706
21. lawandrew
22. Allie
23. zipzip(不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
24. bobo
25. mylulu007 (唔駛交$400就真)
26. Y123
27. cw-kk
28. Happy&Happy (其實請一個外庸=?多一位小朋友, 對小康之家來說, 真係好重負擔架.)
29. yin2002(我幾年都冇人工加!!!)
30. blythe
31. 高鈴 (取消$400/月 LEVY)
32. mamamia (淨係記得對外傭要公平, 甘對我地d中產又唔見對公平d, 你估我地好歎, 特別請個工人來享受, 其實係做埋搵埋都唔夠, 唔覺意請左個垃圾返來, 仲想死)
33. mickeywinnie3
34. 姑姑
35. mymelody2003
36. DoReMi媽媽
37. markbean
38. Kandl
39. hehalady
40. blythe
41. Paulchen1
42. rainbowshiu
43. cheukcheuk(支持取消外傭稅!
44. 1357
45. 3littlepigs
46. rubyhappy2
47. 開門見山(請特首體恤民意為衣歸,保障外傭僱主)
48. Barbara
49. mocha
50. BO_BO
51. HongCheong [?解只係同傭人唸,唔同?我?返工一族唸.唔通本地工人會減價?]
52. E&J
53.jurlique (要求減收外傭稅, 要增加外傭試用期, 取消最低工資, 由市場自行調節)
(攪番個遊行比我地班可憐僱主申怨)
54. karen8888
55. 2jmama
56. winny
57. J&D (可以取消就最好啦, 就算減半都照殺, 仲有請求, 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票就ok)
58.Lemon7831
59.rrrr
60.Fionyiu
61. Hellodaddy + 太太 (係時候檢討外傭政策!)
62.abbytang
63.yellow
64. jennysky
65.QQ2003
66. cat_house
67.kc2021 (養個工人, 要用幾多錢呀? 生/養/教一個小朋友又要幾多錢呀 ? 現時政府重話鼓勵我地生多幾個, 邊個支持我地, 工人有問題, 僱主要補足比佢地走, 小朋友有問題, 家長又要付責任. 我們一一都知道, 但希望政府能夠明白我地, 唔減外傭稅, 不如比個外傭稅免稅額我地, 大家話好唔好)
68. ckckcktina
69. Krymum
70.purplebbbb
71.KWANWAILIN
72.雪瑩媽咪 (我都覺得我地做左boss既責任,應該俾番個外傭免稅額我地)
73.HeiShun_Mum
74.emilylisa
75.Matt_Matt
76.心遂
77.jaycie
78. Charlotteling
79. Auntie-DOS
80.焯嵐媽咪
81.summer_66
82.Fireman
83.Kinki_ma
84.Jacqueline_law
85Hoiyingw
86. 小草
87. steffany
88. CW-KK
89.bbkingdom
90.winnie_sh (外傭嘈完話要番$400就加$80...咁依家輪到僱主要求政府減外傭稅，否則呢次廿幾萬僱主要走出黎，睇黎政府都會好頭痛，快D派糖俾番D僱主順番條氣)
91. twinsmama
92. sylvia wong
93.sunnyman
94. talkative
95. EmilyBB
96. MAXIMS ($2000/月 就合理)
97.catcatmom
98.Jacqueline310
99.KaKaYa
100. meowmi
101. B珠Mummy
102. sylviawu
103. 芝達（唔知點解要幫外傭訂定最低工資，本地工人就冇呢個福利？其實你畀二千，個工人肯做，又關政府乜事呢？）
104. lui_BB
105. phoebemama
106.BB頭maimimi (如果鼓勵生育,就唔該幫下手節省家庭開支啦!)
107. tteresa (其實我既收入已經剛好比左工人同自己既車費, 但怕自己照顧bb將來找唔番野做, now想生多過都唔敢怕到時又話要加人工比佢地, 我已經幾年無加人工啦)
108. sanlap (係咪要我O地生三個先? 如果係, 曾生你的外傭政策同你要求相遺背喎!)
109.bkmummy
(政府又想我?生多d, 但係又唔諗?個個多數都係
因為冇人湊先至要請外傭, 並唔係因為我?有好多
錢而請佢?, 政府提供兒女免稅額又小, 仲有學費
減免條件大部份人都享受唔倒, 政府真係應該好好
諗d方案.
以我自己家庭為例 : 家庭每月收入2萬, 供樓8仟,
工人薪金+外傭稅+insurance4仟, 兩個女現同時
入讀幼稚園4仟(享受唔倒學費減免), 剩下的便時
家庭開支, 根本入不敷支, 我相信有很多家庭ㄕp
我一樣, 政府你們真的應該為我們這些家庭諗?.)
110. ks
111. meifun
112. willin
113. Opheliamama
114. Dorothy
115. ksma
116. 靚媽媽
117. haileymama
118. 肥仔媽咪 (你話外傭稅用來交俾政府都算啦, 但用來補貼再陪訓局)
119. appleapple2006
120. kfwong---(請外庸只不過為湊小朋友,並不是我地好有錢, 而家工人的人工比起其他國家高好好多。)
121.appleyuen
122.Joann
123. Sephina
124. 貝貝
125.wwc
126. dolphin (應該取消交$400至得)
127.Sammiy (支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收)
128.edentiffany
129.Coco926
130.conniengor
131.Sabinamama (救救政府比條生路我地一班中產人士吧. 我今期要交成相等於2個月人工的稅. 家陣又話要加工人人工....放過我啦....救命呀)
132.kilna
133.芷殷
134.nami-nami
135.WINNIEYIP
136. winkylee (支持要取消400蚊外傭稅 , 取消加薪,上年先加完, 今年又加, 天理何在!!)
137.pearlinamok
138. kookamfai
139. puifun
140. sa_mama
141. bellalp (佢?d外傭做得唔好, 炒佢又要補; 我?唔係有錢人呀, 請佢?都係為世所逼, 為?份工咋 !!)
142. babycancan
143.天MO豬媽咪
144. magicmirror
145.傻鴨菇芝
146.busymami
147. bby (佢地仲好福利過我老公喇 )
148.Peggyst
149. 瘋口組
150. PrinceWong
151. Isis_Iain
152. Ada_pang (不侈望唔使交，只希望能將外佣稅調低至200元)
153. kwankit
154. cc&longlong
155. shalie (特首鼓勵我地生3個,但係又比吾到實質支持,我地係出面做餐c,都無人工加,反而個工人加完$50又$80...我地d苦況,特首究竟了解幾多?我地除左出糧比工人,又食又住又保險(好多時claim吾足),開支真係好大,子女駛費又多,返左工又驚工人對bb吾好,我地d壓力可真不少.....)
156. 布甸仔媽媽 (而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670, 係咪有問題ar )
157.甜芋
158. joyce & roy
159.Cheachea
160.chistybbmama
161.Josephine
162. rchu01
163. alalma
164. kachunma
165. littlebirdbird
166. prettymama
167. moomin10
168. Melody1234
169. bb-lam
170. Hviy
171.emilychoy
172.ntkwong
173. carmenyip
174. Whitesnow
175. chumama05 (去年加一次, 今年又加, 但d稅又唔減, 我地又冇人工架, 小朋友學費又咁貴, 咁我地d打工仔點挨呀, 係咪要轉行羅綜援)
176. esmehouse
177. rosannaching重有可吾可以不給工人一個月工資 同回程機票?因為工人偷我地野,重要比錢佢好吾公平
178. Fayme
179. ManLam
180. ChloeMak舉晒腳讚誠減收外傭徵稅, 咁快又加, 想我?死咩, Total 成$3800+日常起居飲食, 加加埋成４千幾, 點頂呀! 政府?然今年賺咁多稅,不如分返Ｄ比我?啦, 200蚊都好呀!
181. jessieoh - 本地工人都無最低工資, 點解香港政府唔protect香港人架?
182. Yvonnehon -- 政府成日手指咬出唔咬入, 我?香港人都無最低工資啦, 點解又唔立例喎!
183.SILVIA......快D取消外僱稅啦......唔該!
184.烏龍媽咪
185. mandywan00..我仲未加人工喎！
186. carolyktong...咪係，我都無人工加，點解要加比佢喎！
187.Karson ma
188. Jenny1234…支持取消外傭稅或直接向外傭徵收, because 而家$3400 + $400 levy 仲多過未交levy $3670.
And 外傭應該有一個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票!!!
189. longlongb
190. tungtungma814 仲加
191. vnice (1.現今請外傭已經不是為"奢侈"的生活享受,絕大部份家庭都只為照顧小孩或老人家,實在是無可奈何之策.2.請外傭的家庭並不代表"富裕",相反都是中產階層,政府要提高外傭薪金,無論加多少,對聘有外傭家庭實在是一個長遠負擔 3.政府稅收充裕,毋須在中產開刀,令大家百上加斤 4.政府徵收外傭稅,美其名為"培訓",徵收以來,未見有實質行動,外傭質素亦未見提高,相反外傭虐待幼兒的新聞屢見不鮮,請再檢討是否有收外傭稅之必要! 5. 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,工積金又要供,薪酬增幅未能同步,亦不足以抵銷開支上的增加,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!)
192. anitapooh--淨賺！包食包住包醫療，不用交通不用靚衫！
193.CKMA (取消$400外傭稅)
194. Hkbuffet
195. gegemok. 我覺得所有野應該由市場定價,為什麼要有最低工資呢? 為什麼政府要攪亂自由市場?如果佢地真係值咁多錢,我地比得少,佢地都唔來啦!!??香港人都未有最低工資? 請問香港政府 d 錢由那裡來, 為什麼手指"咬"出,唔"咬"入,支持減收外傭稅~~又或者支付外傭的費用可減薪俸稅.
196. qqmom (Yes, 請體察民情,物價向上,樓按息口向上,幼稚園學費不減,薪酬不增幅,聘外傭的家庭,每月除月薪,還要供食住,水電煤醫雜,有薪假期回鄉機票,每月平均共要付約$5,600. 外傭的生活質素可能比傭主還好得多!100% agree. ) Actually if the people hire more than one maid in hong kong then they have to pay the extra fee to government but not from us.)
197. Tinnie (可以取消就最好啦, 外傭應該有三個月試用期, 如果黎到貨不對辦send back淨係比機票 香港工人都有試用期, 點解外傭放假一樣,試用期不同....)
198. 哪哪 (政府完全不需要咨詢任何意見,就加外傭人工,但是大部份人的工資就沒有加過。外傭工資就在一年內左右加了兩次，這樣做變相加重僱主負責。根本很多僱主的工資都不是很高.政府這樣做會造成更加多的婦女要放棄自己的工作,而選擇在家照顧自己的小朋友.)
199. Cookie99 (I haven't expense more than $1000 a month for my personal belongings and leisure expenses)
200. Mrs.Chan(請體恤民間疾苦)
201. Betty媽咪 (請工人是無可奈何, 2個小朋友無人看管, 加外傭人工都算, 但400元徵稅實在太重, 頂唔順. 自己咁多年都冇人工加, 希望政府派粒糖比我地, 無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫唔該!)
202.Stella.yam(要加都應該以經驗黎加,唔係話加就加)
203.sausauma
204.LydiaWong
205.henrymama (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 外傭加薪又是用咩標準, 有無咨詢過? 是否太過隻手遮天, 妄顧香港人的利益?)
206. doristsang
207. lui_ho ((香港打工仔邊有咁幸福...有最低工資+兼老細交埋稅+唔駛俾千蚊租屋供樓?!?!?!發夢!!! 我自己一個月都冇三千幾蚊零用呀!!!!!))
208. luluma (傭稅減半, 支持到底, 又再加薪, 僱主加辛)
209. ronleung
210. samwin
211.瑤瑤媽媽
212.Noddy-mammy(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
213. pandafong (不如開放內地既保母市場啦,有競爭先有進步呀)
214.jacquesl(我減?人工之後都未加過一蚊，點解佢地加完又加？)
215. CINDYC
216. smilesun
217. JCLEE
218. 225333 (公務員加薪都要進行咨詢同評估, 到而家都仲涷緊薪!即使私人公司都唔係真係咁好境啦!點解外傭可以加完咁快又加???外傭加薪係用咩標準, 有無咨詢過?強烈要求爭取傭主在申報薪俸稅中可扣除外傭薪金的支出!
219. Blakema
220. FK (no consultation stage, only govt say then get money from our pockets. Foreign domestic helpers have no probation period, got 100% medical coverage, they don't have to pay transportation, rent & rates, food, water, gas and electricity. Govt claimed that all DHs came to HK with at least 2 years experience, how our govt guarantee their working experiences are true and suitable for their employers. We heard foreign DHs ill-treat children from time-to-time but I have no choice to let a stranger to take care of my little children because I must go out to work to maintain my family.
Companies, organisations - salaries and benefits for employees are tax deductible, why we have to pay tax, foreign DHs enjoy lot of benefits (any body here <BK> enjoy 100% medical coverage?) but as employers, we cannot claim tax deduction?
I strongly believe many employers of foreign DHs are not rich. Like me, we believe in a small flat, my DH has to share a room with my CHILDREN. Our govt should not impose too many restrictions on foreign DHs policies. We do not have minimum salary, why they have? I trust that it should depends on the market rate. If they think our offer is low and not attractive, they can choose not to come.
Interest for mortgage has been increase few times this year, prices for food, medical, school fee, interest classes +++++. On holidays, many DHs just bring food from their employers home. Their living standard are higher than some of their employers. At least we only stay at home or go to the garden nearby during holiday because transportation fare is quite expensive particularly for a whole family.
Can all the messages here reach our Chief Executive Donald Tsang and get a fair response?
221. Babyjerry
222. BabyHazel~無奢望400元唔駛比, 減一半都好丫, 調整到200元丫
223.sharonli210
224.羊媽咪
225. Greenrainbow
226. 一家三口
227.櫻桃小貓子
228. conyyan 頂力支持
229. 富安開心媽-四個月內慘遭兩女傭玩謝;菲姐一個月不習慣香港生活,補多一個月錢加機票送她走,換印姐前又補4個月徵款先,她做了3個月走路,果3個月無得退,而家未揀新工人,好慘,所以支持減徵款,同時抗議唔聲唔聲又加合約人工.
230.citadel -外傭僱主才是真正的香港人，為香港的繁榮進步默默作出貢獻（給老闆剝削）！若果特區政府未能採取適當的措施保障外傭僱主的合理和合法權益，受影響的便是我們的下一代！有權就必有責，試想像外傭質素持續下降的當兒，不對「違法亂紀」的外傭加強懲處，就如多次涉嫌犯下虐兒、欺詐、行騙、盜竊等罪行的外傭竟然可以因證據不足而逍遙法外，仍可以一再申請來港工作的！這樣又怎會有人敢再來響應特首生三個小孩的呼籲（來承擔未來供養老化人口的重擔）！亦會令外傭僱主有後顧之憂，勢將削弱香港的生產力，特區政府不可不察！
231.KRISTINE 頂力支持
232.nonno123支持
233.veronica1210
234. Charis支持
235 Swimming
1. 無民意，有無同我地班顧主商量 (我地才係俾錢個個)
2. 政府話要保障本地工人，我地LEVY照交，但個衰工人走?，我地又有什麼保障
3. 我地返工都要自己安排交通費，佢地一個唔該，"我唔做" (有d根本就係自由行，今日到你屋企，發覺唔係一個五星級的家，明天便要你送佢返去)，便要我地買埋機票送到佢地返屋企門口
4. 要請工人的家庭，相信大多也是經濟需要兩公婆外出工作
236. LumLum (點解香港打工仔冇最低工資, 但外傭就有呢d保障????)
237.winnie lau
238.sinkiukiu
239.Brandanmama 頂力支持!!!
240.espirt
241.必必 - 外傭來香港打工, 食, 住唔駛錢, 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買田買地, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 自己身為香港居民都無此保障. 真係天埋何在?
政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意, 另仲要交外傭稅, 政府真係以為香港經濟好好, 但係有好多人幾年都無人工加過啦!
242.文卓媽媽-kat 支持支持 取消$400外傭稅, 政府有訓練過你或我個外傭嗎 ? 點解無人知道 ?
243. Joeystar: 支持支持支持支持
245. Christine
246. 快樂Ah咪
247. littlepig (政府次次話加就加, 完全沒有聽取民意及尊重我們有交稅的"香港人")
248.??同意完全同意唔洗交或減收外傭徵稅
249.terecyy
250. Wendy518-Sum Sum 咪
251. joenam-I've written to Labour Department and copied to the major political parties to express our objection to the increment of minimum allowable wage for foreign domestic helpers.
252. Beryl 88318
253.Woodyryan(我都五年無人工加反而減左兩次，特首大人你有無了解清楚我地有幾困迫，外傭條例已經偏袒勞方，仲要再唔合理地增加最低工資，實在離譜啦！特首大人！請收回承命！造褔百姓！積福積德！
254.jasmine&lun-支持,支持,因養多個工人實在太重皮
255.魚子(比條生路行?啦... )
256.misslee一家
257.pandacat_bb (成日話鼓勵生育, 有冇諗過我?開支有幾大, 我?唔係?綜援, 唔係話生多個, 有多份錢, 樣樣靠自己架咋, 人地日本同法國都比生育獎金啦, 減下稅當幫忙都好呀
258.guy-完完全全應同減收外傭稅，政付應加以體諒我口地在職媽咪！
259. Carmen2004一家
260.915sooky我都好支持
261.FKWhat I feel very unfair for employers of foreign domestic helpers are that:
1. Govt treat us as normal employers, so our employers enjoy 100% benefits, even better than local employees, a typical example is 100% medical coverage, they do not have to pay 1 cent. Though DHs need to pass a medical check before they report duty but it won't check all, right? One of my maid before was admitted to hospital and did operation. I almost became mad during that period. Any boss can tolerate their staff to take leave often to take care of their children (it is merely a personal problem, remember companies are not charity organsation, we cannot ask our employers to be considerate.)
2. No probation period, even they work one day, we have to pay various fees and air tickets.
3. We have to pay tax because we employ foreign domestic helpers, can our government find some HK citizens to help us take care of our children from the time we go to work until we back home?
4. We are the one to pay salary and benefits but have no say in the terms, is it fair to us?
5. Normal employers can include employees' expenses, e.g. salaries, insurance for tax deduction, but we can't. We even have to pay additional tax.
There are few interest increases for mortgage, this already increase my economic burden, I found the prices of food are increasing from time to time, but any of those inflation related to foreign domestic helpers?
6. There are some cases that when foreign DHs maltreat children, their penalty is quite light. Many cases, like stealing, because of no evidence or employers do not want to get trouble and waste time, just terminate their maid but also need to pay one-month-in-lieu of notice. Any employers want to take risk to give a month notice?
7 I just want somebody to take care of my children so that I can go out to work to support my family. I do not get any subsidy from govt. But employ foreign DHs just like being penalised by our govt.
8 Our govt imposed too much restriction on the foreign DHs policy. Why she did not learn those good thing from Singaporean govt?
262. tpmak
263.mnlight73
264.Vanessa8 一家支持支持 取消$400外傭稅
265.咪落地
266.翁心怡, 外傭條例對顧主來說此乃不平等條約, 需急切從新修訂(包括減低外傭稅及降低最低工資)!!
267.gloria_sweet824 -yes, support!!
268. sinwin whole family
269. maysungsung
270. galslide
271. 3KidsMaMa (點解做工人會無試用期, 而有設有最低工資, 點解所有利益歸於工人, 特首呼籲港人生多幾個, 但又唔幫我?想?生完有幾多野要兼顧, 請個工人幫?手, 就反而沒有好處給僱主)
272. vhunghk
273. agnesmama
274. rainbowbb
275. yoballma 係啦, 其實請?個工人, 等於養多?一個人. 又包食, 又包住,所有?都預多一份, 根本同養多個人冇分別. 一闊三大呀.
276. snake (人工又唔見加好多, 樣樣都加價. 加左人工後還要倒貼)
277. charlotte_mom (唔減唔緊要, 唔該啦, 我地有時要中途轉工人, 已經身心疲倦+無奈, 又要賠錢送機票已經好慘, 唔該政府做下好心, 唔好再雪上加霜, 唔好再堅持"先炒舊人再批新人"至可以transfer levy喇, 我地個個都係為生計奔波, 唔"奢侈"得起請2個禮拜假去"替更"...
278. 肥媽咪
279.abby媽
280. yyvenus
281. DuncanMaMa
282. HOYIUMA - 請取消外傭稅, 負擔已經很大
283. cm93002 我地為?兩餐要返工搵錢先迫於無奈將個bb交比d十個有八個衰o既外傭湊，比錢之餘仲要擔驚受怕，
受佢地氣，真係心力交碎，精神衰弱，求下你地大發慈悲唔好樣樣o野都淨係保障晒佢地，我地做顧主o既就有苦自己知
284. yy2004 - 你地政府又話鼓勵我地生bb, 但另一方面又個埋呢d事去打擊我地, 請請你地細心去體會我地生活有幾辛苦...
285. Sweetsoul
286. JENNIFER
287. Feliciamama
288.zoe_tam
289.sesimo
290.corachan(人工無得加 , 邊個幫我地),請盡快取消外傭稅
291.winice-Support + agreed......! 簡直百上加斤呀!!
292. ysmhkg (大力支持)
293. holongmama
294. mandyyml
295. wc
296. yikmanmama
297. carolmama2005
298.yuiyuima 舉手支持
299. JojoB 全力支持
300.paulavincent It's not fair to us
301.PoohPooh123 - Fully support
302. yanyan0629 (除取消外傭徵稅外，我覺得未做滿三個月若被解僱便享有一個月代通知金簡直是不知所謂．勞工署要將外傭跟香港勞工看齊．勞工假，例假甚麼都一樣．為何我們本地勞工於大部分公司工作試用期頭三個月都只是一天或七天通知呢?仲有，政府收咁多$稅，唔該出visa就出快d,要我地等成兩個月先有工人到．比多d＄,工作效率仍不變，真的不合理！)
303. ronna1209--完全同意
304.chanrita1214-住力支持
305.martha.bb--d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;真係返??埋d$成3分1比佢仲要對佢地好d(驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路)........
306.angelalchansm-支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
307.mandicmy-fullly support (全力支持).政府都冇譜,淨?只諗外傭,唔使理我地?立稅人.錢就猛收
308. 卓衡父母
309. bebeyan, 應該減輕中產負擔. thanks !!
310.sidney-I have two babies, they are twins so I feel that is very expensive for me to employ two helper and need to give baby join playgroup.
311. Horlicks - 難為中產人士
312. joeyng--大力支持減輕中產負擔
313. hugo_ma -- 二年儲埋大把, 返家鄉可以買car買house,d外傭質素又唔高,質地又唔好;仲要對佢地好好,驚佢一唔鐘意就攪d細路, 政府仲要設最低工資保障他們, 真係天埋何在? 我地人工又唔見加!
312. BonBon_the_pooh -- 舉手支持
313. florence0204 全力支持
314. blueglass--一年加2次正一特衰政府比董建x拾政時仲要衰100倍
315. mid-mid
316. coreymami
317.KWCHAN -我同老公兩個人搵錢, 又要供樓, 又要養父母, 舊年個仔出世, 無奈之下要請工人, 但人工冇加, 供樓利息加左, 開支大左, 每月支出仲多個收入, 點知仲要話加工人人工, 頂唔順之下炒左佢, 依家淨係亞媽照顧亞仔, 仲要煮埋飯比我地食, 佢老人家好辛苦, 我好心痛, 但冇辦法, 咁多把口要食, 咁樣點敢再生? 仲話生三個, 我驚比人話不孝播!
318. Kathy
319. godivachoc (唔取消?話, 就應該將依d外傭人工放埋入稅單到減稅!)
320. rm_cn (你估我們想要工人咩, 無辦法之嗎)
321. cmsfish( 我未有家傭, 因為手續繁複,錢銀多多, 法津保障佢?多過我?, 咁多錢請個人住在自己家中, 文化又唔同.真係好冒險, 問政府一句, 點敢生bb呀? 仲話呼籲巿民生多?. 教育又唔好, 請好既傭工又難, 而且又多錢, 點生呀?)
322. 嵐嵐媽咪(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)
323. ChunChunMame-Just like Canada, if you hire a baby sitter to take care of your child, we should get tax deduction as well. Furthemore, only for those we hire more than 1 maid need to pay the $400 tax as well.
324. skching 支持取消或減收外傭徵稅，政府應體恤下我地，唔係只僱住外傭，係亞洲地區佢
地人工都唔係低，我地都係因為生活先要請佢地揍小朋友.......
325. tamannabel (剛續了約人工加了$3400/續約費$3000/保險2年$770/政府稅半年$2400...暫時total:6170未計人工及機票) ...年尾又要交稅....好苦
326. Nattyma
327.chunbaby mama - 支持減$400稅再調低外傭最低工資
328. p&c - 工人自己走.點知佢last day果日就係另一個月levy既starting date.所以冇無拿拿做多1日就咁比多$400.點解唔可以按比例扣返比下一個工人呢.
329.Shingshing&MaMa- 比左錢出去唔緊要, 但工人質素無保障, 作為消費者我地可以去邊度申訴?
330. RyanLeungmama
331. Mrs.Pretty Chan.Yes I agree
332.msllau(支持取消外傭稅及最低工資 , 增加聘請外傭免稅額及3個月試用期內免代通知金&機票 , 修改外傭條例及假期)(年年人工減減減,外傭人工加加加;政府鼓勵生生生,家庭赤字升升升;如斯情況慘慘慘,特首可有想想想)
333.Patty (There should be one month probation! If they did not perform well, we could fire them immediately in the first month. We, HK workers, are submitted to various restrictions. How come Filipino maids have privileges???)
334. 臣媽
335. muicc
336. J&T&Family (一家大細都支持 取消$400外傭稅)!!
337. samantha821 - Fully support
338. 珀珀,慧慧媽 支持
339. peaceworld
發表於 
返回列表
