大仔大女媽媽會 今日: 0 | 主題: 177861

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

581^#

發表於 08-9-3 09:49 |只看該作者

yanyanchan:

我重溫緊part1...睇左一半咋，
==> 你俾心機慢慢睇啦, 睇完你就有好多野唔駛再問架喇...:lol:

想問下東涌區小學你點睇呀??
==>老老實實, 對個區有保留, 所以小學我會 prefer 出外, 但若真係要揀既, 有教會背景既會好少少

如果直資...陳守仁/英華/聖瑪加利/地利亞(閩僑)青衣又好唔好呢!!
==> 陳守仁同英華都勁多人考的, 陳守仁我有講過 (喂喂..要溫書), 佢係以"聯合國 feel" 而聞名, 所以對學習 cultural diversity 係好有用, 語文亦有幫助, 所以多人考, 英華多人考因為係一條龍, 佢中學英華中學亦係傳統名校, 所以家長喜歡佢

St Margaret 一般, 考親都多數收的. Delia 我唔熟, no comment. 不過我一向對 Delia group 既 school 印象都麻麻, 因為佢 history 太耐, 但我知既都係d 麻麻既 history. 不過 maybe 區區既 Delia 都會有唔同既.

你有冇好提議呀??
==> 提議乜...? 小學...?? If 你想考直資既, 近你個區既都唔係好多既, 可以考哂先, 收先再比較啦.

私人傳訊

bb@wonderland

積分: 1462

582^#

發表於 08-9-4 18:36 |只看該作者

彥媽, 你好!

(Sorry for using English, my Chinese typing skill is not good).

I found your forum, when I am searching school info for my boy. I really said “Wa Wa” when I found it. You are really wonderful.

I copy and paste your “精華區” into the word file, do you know, it has 82 pages. I think you can publish a book, should have many fans!.

I used a week to scan through 精華區 and Part 2, Part 1 (started a few pages). I will go through them again, as it is very informative!

Sorry that, I have not finished my “homework” before asking you, your comment.

First of all, my boy is Nov 06 kid. I have applied PN for this school year (插班). As I live in Tiu Keng Leng, not much choice, so I pick two kinders, just next to MTR station.
1) Lam Tin Creative (accept him, start school in Feb, 09)
2) Hang Hau Greenville (accept him, start school in Dec, 09)
(But they both are not my target school for K1)

Reasons for studying PN:
- to gain experience for a social life
- to learn some more about self-care ability
- better communication/ language ability
- hope to have a better performance during K1 interview (such as St. Cat.)

I read your comments on these 2 schools already:
Creative – Depends if you buy “活動教學” or not
Greenville – just a ordinary kinder
Still want to seek your opinion which of these 2 kinders is better for achieving the above objectives?

My dream school for primary – St. Jo and 華仁, so I need to go through the game - “relationship” and “luck”. With only 20 marks, I know my chance in 1st round is low. So I may consider move home to Wanchai, for getting a chance in 2nd round. One of my friend suggest me trying SPK or SPN, as boys are limited, school may help if the boys cannot get a seat into a desirable primary school. But I am thinking if it is not good for a boy studying in a girl’s environment during the entire kinder life, any imbalance would be happened? What are your comments on this? Also SPK and SPN mostly accept 大仔, so I need to let him study one more year, Do you think it is worth to do so? Another option is Study in SPK/SPN and then apply St. Jo K2, some people said chances are higher. If I want to apply St. Jo K2, which kinders (K1) are better?

I will also apply DSS and private school, what do you think about 優才? I know you concern more on the school “history”, and優才 may not be your type, apart from history, do you have any comments?

Sorry for asking too many questions, thanks in advance for your time and patience.

[ 本文章最後由 bb@wonderland 於 08-9-4 19:46 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

Isaac_Ma

積分: 3473

583^#

發表於 08-9-4 19:18 |只看該作者

彥媽，我知你的規矩要溫書家麻！但實在太多，我估你應該有講過德望，大約响邊度，可唔可以講我聽，等我可以容易D搵到。
叧外，如果將德望同培正比較，响功課量同學習成績的要求，你會點睇呢？

私人傳訊

samman

別墅

積分: 792

584^#

發表於 08-9-6 11:09 |只看該作者

彥媽媽,

我係路過架, 好開心知道有一個咁熱心又樂於助人既媽咪...相信你既仔仔們都一定喺你身上獲益良多la...
我睇咗精華篇...不過就未睇PART 1 & PART 2, 希望你唔好介意la..我有以下問題想問呀,

我係平民新手媽咪嚟, 仔仔依家先得幾個月人仔, 初時諗住唔需要太急搵學校, 但眼見好多家長都係咁早...所以都攪到有少少急...想仔仔可以早d入學先讀n1 (若有需要就之後轉讀k1)...我只係想小朋友讀得開開心心同學倒野....心儀幼園係九龍塘糧靈堂 or 鑽石山糧靈堂...
1.請問呢兩間既雜費甘唔甘呢?
2. 係咪要依家就報咗名留位先呢?
3. 會唔會有其他而又好既選擇....?? (如禮賢會 or 救世軍)

私人傳訊

caba

積分: 1642

585^#

發表於 08-9-6 21:54 |只看該作者

彥媽,

有野請教：
請問培正小一係唔係一定只收六歲既學生呢？係唔係好似幼稚園咁嚴謹，少一日都冇機？

咁考小一係唔係同插班小二等一樣要有特異功能呢？
Thanks

另外，我見到你發表既「入去學校打工」既偉論勁正，我都有諗過同留意緊

因小妹乃中學教師，我教間都Band 1，但就唔係頭既，同其實都好唔想自已個仔女讀自已教既學校啦！雖然n年後都應該唔會教書！其實十個有九個都唔想，真係除非間野Band 1Top啦！
我真係有諗過，借間有邊間好野中小學同一校址既呢！

[ 本文章最後由 caba 於 08-9-6 22:03 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

jjtseung

伯爵府

積分: 15067

586^#

發表於 08-9-8 06:52 |只看該作者

彥媽,

我係度咪緊書... 不過都仲未咪完part I... 繼續努力中!

我想同女女(0612)係09年1月插班N1, 想請問以下兩間邊間會適合些, 因為兩間都係差唔多口埤, 差唔多性質:

1. 基督教服務處時代幼兒學校: 9月1日新轉校長, 新校長之前係匯豐幼兒學校校長, 尤其重視音樂藝術上的潛能發展...

2. 聖雅各福群會銅鑼灣幼兒中心: 雖然有聖雅各小學, 不過佢地07/08年得3個入呢間小學, 其他大多自由發揮!

兩間的校舍都唔大, 無outdoor, 不過2就近我少少(我住北角), 同埋2靠近中央圖書館&紀律部隊會(唔使搭車), 放佐學可以帶女女去圖書館or游水!

仲有我來緊都會同女女報K1~~~ 聖保祿, 聖馬加利大, 寶血等, 雖然女女各方面發展尚算幾好, 19個月前自己睇書間中睇DVD識晒26個字母, 1-10數字(中英文), 語言, 大小肌肉同社交亦都唔錯(佢而加返緊保護兒童會的托嬰, 好enjoy返學)... 不過因為佢係12月尾的細女, 家陣又有晒trouble 2的衰野, 我對interview時佢的表現都無mud信心! 加埋佢自滿月到而加, 都係個7/8點就訓覺, 朝早6點起身的早睡早起寶寶, 所以, 我唔考慮pm班, 更難!
所以, 如果做唔到細B, 就繼續N2... 出年再考SPN, SPK, 做大女!

唔知我咁ge想法正路嗎?
多謝賜教! 萬分感謝!

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

587^#

發表於 08-9-8 11:47 |只看該作者

bb @ wonderland

係有好多篇的, 你要慢慢睇, 睇完就有好多野你唔駛問, or 會問另一d 野架喇...

I read your comments on these 2 schools already:
Creative – Depends if you buy “活動教學” or not
Greenville – just a ordinary kinder
Still want to seek your opinion which of these 2 kinders is better for achieving the above objectives?
==>我會話兩間都得, 只係兩間既 learning mode 唔同, 開心愉快, 有 social life...etc...基本上間間都會俾得到, 只要有同齡小朋友一齊亙相學習影響就好 OK, 至於學自理, nursery 會學得好過 KG, 關於呢點, 你可以睇返我之前講 difference between nursery and KG 就知...語言, KG 因為學術d , 自會講多d...活動教學亦做好多 encourage students to participate, speak up...呢類野, 但 normal KG 都唔會差好遠...至於你話要考學校, 睇你想考邊d 啦...super 名校既話, 去d 有名既幼稚園會好d 既, Creative 優勢在於佢d students 都幾主動, 所以 interview 時都有幫助, 不過講到尾都係小朋友本身係唔係 outspoken, proactive 呢d 會係主菜. 仲有, 識到幾多野去答問題都係 one factor, and for this point 家長要 train 就少不免, 唔可以單憑學校, 從以往 past record 睇, 好多間間名校都收既學生既家長背後都係做左好多功夫的..唔係單入幼稚園就算架 (除非本身有 network 就另計), 當然, 你唔著眼名校既就唔駛太擔心了.

My dream school for primary – St. Jo and 華仁, so I need to go through the game - “relationship” and “luck”. With only 20 marks, I know my chance in 1st round is low.
==> 唔駛灰心 here, 20 分有得抽的, 你係 Catholics, right? In that case, 1st round 都叫有得搏丫...起碼好過我地一分都冇個d 架喇...事實係有人 20 分 first round 抽入的, 相對黎講, 20 分抽 St Jo chance 面大過 Wah Yan, 因為佢學額多過 WY

So I may consider move home to Wanchai, for getting a chance in 2nd round. One of my friend suggest me trying SPK or SPN, as boys are limited, school may help if the boys cannot get a seat into a desirable primary school. But I am thinking if it is not good for a boy studying in a girl’s environment during the entire kinder life, any imbalance would be happened?
==> Personally 我唔太鍾意男女比例太大差別既學校, 好似 SPK, SPN 咁, 多數都係女仔入的, 男仔係好少, 不過 if that is not your concern 咁就冇問題既....考得入都真係讀得過, 不過另一 choice I would suggest 既係...因為 SPK , SPN 都唔會預你阿仔上小學, 另一方面佢學費亦唔平 (esp SPN) , 咁響冇乜優勢 to 仔既情況下, 雖然 imbalance 唔會好 obvious at this level, 但我只係睇唔到佢 why 冇任何對我有利既因素下我要 take this gum la.... 我係你我會寧取 KC (蘇浙), budget OK 既讀埋佢國際班 (till K1), 加強佢英語能力, 去考 St Jo KG (佢只由 K2 起), 咁就算到時 1st round 唔得, 2nd round 又死埋, 叩門都會因為你係 St Jo KG students 唔多唔少都有d jetso, 唔得既 stay at KC 都冇問題丫..佢小學亦唔差, 係中學先要揾過間啦.

I will also apply DSS and private school, what do you think about 優才? I know you concern more on the school “history”, and優才 may not be your type, apart from history, do you have any comments?
優才, 有名你叫, 佢係為 gifted child 而設立的, 因此, (1) gifted child 會優先 (要交埋 IQ report 的), 學校亦投放好多資源俾 gifted students, 因為一般 normal school 反而唔易做得到, in this case, 我睇法係, unless 你小朋友係 gifted, otherwise 要諗就諗諗真道啦 (if you really want DSS)

[ 本文章最後由彥彥媽咪於 08-9-8 15:31 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

588^#

發表於 08-9-8 11:55 |只看該作者

issac_ma:

彥媽，我知你的規矩要溫書家麻！但實在太多，我估你應該有講過德望，
==> 你知就好啦....

大約响邊度，可唔可以講我聽，等我可以容易D搵到。
==> 咁咪即係我要先自己由頭睇一次先...??:-( 係唔係你慢慢每日幾頁幾頁咁睇會 effective 過我去做呢...

你真係想我話你知既, 你就俾d time 我, 我要慢慢揾的.:lol:

叧外，如果將德望同培正比較，响功課量同學習成績的要求，你會點睇呢？
==> 德望係"嚴謹"型學校, 比培正應會更甚, 但佢位置都幾蝦人, 相對培正會交通方便少少, 而德望係女校, 亦重英文, 培正係 co-ed , 係中文學校, 功課量大家唔會差好遠, 要求都高, 個個冇 8x 分+ 都唔掂...因為你比較既重點就係上面呢類 info 會有用d.

之前曾有家長在 "小學雜談" 個邊 post 過 "德望 vs 培正" , 你有時間可以 search 番慢慢睇下.

私人傳訊

bb@wonderland

積分: 1462

589^#

發表於 08-9-8 12:21 |只看該作者

彥媽,

Thanks a lot for your time and comments. Really appreciated so much.

Just one more Question: If apply for St. Jo kinder (K2), do you think SPK/SPN students have a greater chance than KC students?

原文章由 彥彥媽咪 於 08-9-8 11:47 發表
bb @ wonderland

係有好多篇的, 你要慢慢睇, 睇完就有好多野你唔駛問, or 會問另一d 野架喇...

I read your comments on these 2 schools already:
Creative – Depends if you buy “活動教學” or not
Greenvil ...

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

590^#

發表於 08-9-8 15:23 |只看該作者

caba:

請問培正小一係唔係一定只收六歲既學生呢？係唔係好似幼稚園咁嚴謹，少一日都冇機？
==> 係, 插班都係...即係就算插 K2 都要足 4 歲, 插小二都係足 7 歲之類 (before Aug 31)....

咁考小一係唔係同插班小二等一樣要有特異功能呢？
==> 試 put yourself in the shoes of 校長, 當你間學校成日都成村人等插班, 而你間學校流動率又唔係高, 因此插班位 (多數仲係靠留班位先叫有位) 都係得個一兩個既時候, 咁有得咁多人俾你揀 for 呢一兩個位既時候, 你會唔會是但邊個入表先就收邊個呢...?? 定係你都想揀d 叻, 醒既去"為學校爭光" 呢....so you should be able to answer your question on your own la...

都係個句, "有關係"者另當別論...:lol::" />

另外，我見到你發表既「入去學校打工」既偉論勁正，我都有諗過同留意緊
==> 乜你唔知之前有個 case 係: 有個阿媽佢老公係有錢人... 本身都係闊太唔駛做的了, 但因為想個仔入喇沙, 佢就係就去應徵教佢小學, 又真係入到, but of course 之前冇人知佢係因為咁入去教喇...大家只係知....once 佢個仔入到去之後佢就 resign la...後來d 人想 find out why 佢做咁短時間就 resign 大家先 find out "原來如此" 之嘛...報紙都有登出黎架 wor, 你冇留意咩...此乃真人真事呀....何奇之有...HK 人有乜方法諗唔出黎丫...哈哈~~~

不過..要有名校教都係唔多唔少有關係係樹, unless 教個d subject 唔係大路科 (即係冇人肯教個d 喇), 唔係想入去都有一定既難度架...

因小妹乃中學教師，我教間都Band 1，但就唔係頭既，同其實都好唔想自已個仔女讀自已教既學校啦！
==>why lei? 係唔想有 conflict of interest (愛之深, 責之切個停??!) 定係你都對自己間學校有保留先?

喂喂...你唔俾阿仔, 我d 仔好想入架 wor...我地唔貪心去 top band 1 ga...band 1 尾都 lur 飯應架, 識你有冇 jetso 先, 幫幫手丫~~

ops:" />

雖然n年後都應該唔會教書！其實十個有九個都唔想，真係除非間野Band 1Top啦！
==>HK ...唉...教書...莫講唔係 band 1 , even band 1 又如何? 我唔係好見到學生 (or even parents) 有幾識得 respect 同 appreciate 老師為學生做既野, 好多時我睇到既係 criticism 既多, 而唔係先 self-reflecting 自己家庭管教如何, 仔女行為如何, etc...都真係好教為師者灰心架....就算真係 band 1 , 學生考得好你認為家長 or even 學生自己又會認為係老師都係 one of the most important contributing factors 咩....I guess not really bor...都幾 discouraging ga....:cry:

我真係有諗過，借間有邊間好野中小學同一校址既呢！
==> 嗱...又同你分析下...你話嘞, 要一間學校可以有埋小學中學一齊, 塊地皮係咪要有番咁上下大先得丫....好嘞, 咁依家 HK 地, 地少人多, 又去邊樹仲揾得到咁大塊地皮俾你又起操場, 又起課室, 仲要有埋中小學丫...答案係...冇丫嘛...so for sure 新校你唔駛旨意, so in that case, 一定只係d 老牌 long history 學校先有喇 (因為 N 年前起落架嘛...) 咁 N 年前起落個d 又到依家都仲"健在"既可以靠咩呢...?? 一定只有 2 reasons : (a) 間學校好掂, 收生多到你唔揀, 即係個 22 間傳統名校囉 (e.g. St Mary ar, Wah Yan ar, La Salle ar, Marymount ar gum la)...再唔係就係 (b) 學校校董會好有錢...多到可以自己俾錢起哂中小學 (e.g. d 新派直資就得喇...eg. HKUGA ar, some new DSS ar gum la)

so in this case, 你手指數埋咪又係個幾間喇....唔駛我再講你都應該知邊幾間喇...hehe...

:lol::" />

[ 本文章最後由彥彥媽咪於 08-9-8 15:58 編輯 ]

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

591^#

發表於 08-9-8 15:30 |只看該作者

bb @ wonderland:

Just one more Question: If apply for St. Jo kinder (K2), do you think SPK/SPN students have a greater chance than KC students?

==> no ..從來冇明顯數據顯示有此情況...每年有幾個入到此事不足為奇, KC 都有一樣... Kentville 考過去仲多, 咁又代表乜呢....

Even 有人問埋係唔係父母職業呀, 住響邊呀會有 impact 呢...?? so too many influencing factors, schools 只係 one of them....

so 除非人地 St Jo 講明只收 SPN/SPK 就收, otherwise 我都唔會多信, 世事無絕對, 上一屆係咁 =/= 今年都係.. so unless 校長出哂面幫埋口同 St Jo 講我就會信會得, 因呢d 叫做"關係", 唔叫考入), 不過我亦唔認為校長會人人都幫, 亦唔會因為呢d 唔係 100% 既期望而考入去 (我鍾意間學校就另計), 因為唔想到時失望.

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

592^#

發表於 08-9-8 15:47 |只看該作者

samman:

我係路過架, 好開心知道有一個咁熱心又樂於助人既媽咪...相信你既仔仔們都一定喺你身上獲益良多la...
==> 先多謝你讚賞...

不過...熟彥媽既朋友就知...彥媽既熱心係要雙方面架...即係你要溫書我先會熱心 ga wor...知冇...唔係的話, 我唔啋你 bor ... 知冇~~hehe...

我係平民新手媽咪嚟, 仔仔依家先得幾個月人仔, 初時諗住唔需要太急搵學校, 但眼見好多家長都係咁早...所以都攪到有少少急...想仔仔可以早d入學先讀n1 (若有需要就之後轉讀k1)...我只係想小朋友讀得開開心心同學倒野....心儀幼園係九龍塘糧靈堂 or 鑽石山糧靈堂...
1.請問呢兩間既雜費甘唔甘呢?
==> 唔可以用"甘"形容既, 呢兩間比佢九龍塘個d 私立幼稚園差成條街架喇....不過係都有好多濕碎野你要比咁囉...反而 other 普通個d or even 慈善團體辦個d 就多數係收一個學費就算, 唔會樣樣再另同你計錢...for details, 你可以去 EDB 個 web 樹揾幼稚園既 info, 每間都有寫收幾錢學費同 other 收費的. 關於靈糧堂, 我之前有講過的, 你個仔幾個月之嘛...夠時間比你溫哂書先既...hehe, no hurry~~

2. 係咪要依家就報咗名留位先呢?
==> Normally 學校係 18 months+ 先比你報的, 你擔心冇位既係可去問同報既... 不過都你要先明白, 學生收生係睇供求的, 即係佢地唔夠學生既話就全天候都會收人 (因為每間幼稚園都有收生上限的, 係要按老師人手比例, 地方大細而定, 大d 地方既, 人手多既就可以收多d 學生咁囉), 所以, 有d 學校 if locate 係d 出生率低既地區, 又唔多同類型學校 nearby 既, 咁佢 ngai 你讀都黎唔切啦, 駛乜一早去報名呢...不過...if 你想去個間成日都好多人報既, 就要早d 問定咁啦. 事實上, 好多爭崩頭個d 學校係唔會比你咁早報名的, 因為佢地知道一 call application 大把人爭, so why bother 全天候處理呢d 事宜呢 (admin 麻煩嘛), 好多時係收生唔易 full 個d 先反而會一早就俾你報, 咁你一報, 佢就即收你可以先 lock 左你丫嘛....明冇..??

3. 會唔會有其他而又好既選擇....?? (如禮賢會 or 救世軍)
==> 你有溫我書的話就會知我講過其實 at KG level , 間間唔會真係差好遠, 所以著眼點唔會係"學乜野", 而係接送上, 返學時間上, 師生數目比例上...地方環境上...etc....呢d 先應為較大既考慮點, 你再 continue 溫書啦, 睇多d 你就會明架喇...:lol

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

593^#

發表於 08-9-8 15:56 |只看該作者

jjtseung:

我係度咪緊書... 不過都仲未咪完part I... 繼續努力中!
==> 加油, 我支持你..!!! :lol:

1. 基督教服務處時代幼兒學校: 9月1日新轉校長, 新校長之前係匯豐幼兒學校校長, 尤其重視音樂藝術上的潛能發展...

2. 聖雅各福群會銅鑼灣幼兒中心: 雖然有聖雅各小學, 不過佢地07/08年得3個入呢間小學, 其他大多自由發揮!
==> 我揀幼兒園唔會先睇佢派邊間小學, 因為派邊間小學同你讀邊間幼稚園 (or 幼兒園) 無關 (if you join 阿公搞珠), 除非你想考超級名小學既話 (DSS 個停) 啦, 否則你依家呢兩間都冇問題丫...最緊要大同多空間就好, 對小朋友身體好, 你有睇我精華篇就會記得我講過揀幼兒園較著重既野, 唔係學野, 係體能, 健康我會較睇重.

兩間的校舍都唔大, 無outdoor, 不過2就近我少少(我住北角), 同埋2靠近中央圖書館&紀律部隊會(唔使搭車), 放佐學可以帶女女去圖書館or游水!
==> 你覺得 OK 就得啦, 始終要每日接送, 仲要預埋打風落雨, 細路頭暈身慶呢d 突發事件, so 方便家長會係 one very important factor ga...

仲有我來緊都會同女女報K1~~~ 聖保祿, 聖馬加利大, 寶血等, 雖然女女各方面發展尚算幾好, 19個月前自己睇書間中睇DVD識晒26個字母, 1-10數字(中英文), 語言, 大小肌肉同社交亦都唔錯(佢而加返緊保護兒童會的托嬰, 好enjoy返學)... 不過因為佢係12月尾的細女, 家陣又有晒trouble 2的衰野, 我對interview時佢的表現都無mud信心! 加埋佢自滿月到而加, 都係個7/8點就訓覺, 朝早6點起身的早睡早起寶寶, 所以, 我唔考慮pm班, 更難!

所以, 如果做唔到細B, 就繼續N2... 出年再考SPN, SPK, 做大女!

唔知我咁ge想法正路嗎?
==> OK ar....你咁諗 OK 丫...再真係唔好彩考唔到既讀到 N4 再派小學啦, 揾定 DSS/private back up , 再有個好地址就 OK ga la...

私人傳訊

jjtseung

伯爵府

積分: 15067

594^#

發表於 08-9-8 16:50 |只看該作者

原文章由 彥彥媽咪 於 08-9-8 15:56 發表
jjtseung:

我係度咪緊書... 不過都仲未咪完part I... 繼續努力中!
==> 加油, 我支持你..!!! :lol:

1. 基督教服務處時代幼兒學校: 9月1日新轉校長, 新校長之前係匯豐幼兒學校校長, 尤其重視音樂藝術上的潛能發展.. ...

多謝你的答覆同鼓勵!

今日諮詢過個朋友, 佢highly recommand靈糧堂CWB... 佢女女係果度讀, 現在係瑪莉曼讀P3, 佢介紹話, 覺得P1小朋友跟得唔算太辛苦, P2有些辛苦, P3又OK返!

佢女女&佢幾個靈糧堂畢業的同學仔都在班上名列前茅!

真係唔好意思... 我仲未細心study小學! 而加先知小學先至最緊要, 其實以下幾間小學講品德培養&學術&升中成績, 點排位呢?
(我會先考私校/直資, 考唔到再攪珠再叩門)
1. 聖保祿
2. 聖方濟各
3. 瑪莉曼
4. 真光
5. 軒尼詩官小
6. 基灣
我會繼續努力咪書...

多謝!

私人傳訊

禁止訪問

積分: 1172

595^#

發表於 08-9-8 21:55 |只看該作者

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

私人傳訊

huisylvia

積分: 12423

好媽媽勳章畀面勳章

596^#

發表於 08-9-10 00:50 |只看該作者

彥媽，你好，因為工作關係，我用咗成個幾月至睇到你Part2，但因為好多學校已經開始收n1，所以未睇晒都要硬住頭皮問下：

我住馬鞍山，bb日頭由住沙田既婆婆湊，為咗婆婆唔使接送太辛苦，所以幼兒院決定喺沙田讀，但婆婆附近既幼稚園或幼兒院大多都喺公共屋村入面，我又唔係好想揀，而家心目中諗係第一城嘉德麗，或者花園城真理浸信會榮光

1. 聽講嘉德麗好深，佢地強調要培養小朋友品德教育，要讀經書，係古文果隻，但考上Band1小學率唔錯，但我又擔心太深，小朋友如果跟唔上會怕咗返學，唔知你對呢間有咩comment？
2. 而榮光就有教會背景，聽人講d老師好好，但我都未太了解，係唔係近似靈糧堂教法呢？
3. 其實我諗住會都轉K1既，咁我係咪俾bb讀咗嘉德麗n1先，如果佢適應就繼續，唔適應先k1轉另一間呢？
4. 或者你又有無推介呢？(第一城附近)
唔該晒！

私人傳訊

elmolly

男爵府

積分: 7423

597^#

發表於 08-9-10 23:47 |只看該作者

彥媽,

唔該晒. 想再問下KC既本班又好唔好?

如果讀Victoria或者KC去考私校/DSS,一般命中率如何?

謝謝.

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

598^#

發表於 08-9-11 09:32 |只看該作者

jjtseung:

今日諮詢過個朋友, 佢highly recommand靈糧堂CWB... 佢女女係果度讀, 現在係瑪莉曼讀P3, 佢介紹話, 覺得P1小朋友跟得唔算太辛苦, P2有些辛苦, P3又OK返! 佢女女&佢幾個靈糧堂畢業的同學仔都在班上名列前茅!
==> 呵呵...基本上我見親d 家長有小朋友讀緊個間幼稚園既, 都一定好支持番佢自己間幼稚園的, 呢個係當然現象, 你睇出面 BK 每間被討論既幼稚園既家長如何為佢地幼稚園出口出力就知

我咁講唔係話唔好, 只係想你明白讀緊/讀完個d 話個間好都係幾必然既現象, 因為唔好個d 都唔會讀到畢業喇...但對佢好等唔等於都對你好呢就係另一回事了, 相信你應該明白箇中道理啦...

真係唔好意思... 我仲未細心study小學! 而加先知小學先至最緊要, 其實以下幾間小學講品德培養&學術&升中成績, 點排位呢?
(我會先考私校/直資, 考唔到再攪珠再叩門)
1. 聖保祿
2. 聖方濟各
3. 瑪莉曼
4. 真光
5. 軒尼詩官小
6. 基灣

==>你有冇睇哂我既答問篇? 有既話上面有一半學校你應該唔駛問架喇 wor...

你做哂d 基本功課未先...?? ie. 上面咁多間, 有d 係私校, 有d係抽獎, 你知唔知..?? 即係話, 有d 唔到你排位啦, 抽得入先講, 你冇分都唔駛點諗 (e.g. Marymount, 冇 20 分唔駛諗, 有都要聽天由命..等抽..)

另, 我再問你...你講既 "聖保祿" 係講邊間? CWB 個間 (I guess?) 係 St Paul's Convent, 你又知唔知 Happy Valley 都有一間叫 "St Paul's Catholics"..前者係私校, 後者係津貼..兩間都係女校, 你想問邊間先....問題唔清楚答唔到 ga wor...

But I guess you are talking about St Paul Convent gwa?

For factual details, 你要先去 EDB 樹睇睇每間學校既資料, 另詳再去溫溫書 pls, 因為好多我都講過的, 就校風而言, 幾間d校風都唔差 ga wor, even 基灣都多 Band 1 生 ga, 之不過佢係地區名校, 同 Marymount, St Paul 呢類較知名既有d 分別啦....另基灣又冇得直升, 真光同 St Paul 係私校, St Paul 又超難考, 因此, 唔係 only 你想就得, 都要 consider 埋成功機會的...講"易入", 軒小同真光都會好過其他 (雖然都唔係太容易,but comparatively speaking with other 4 咁計啦)

Back to your question, 純答你問既野 (品德培養&學術&升中成績), 我會排 Marymount = St Paul > St Francis > Kei Wan > True Light > 軒小.

私人傳訊

積分: 12319

2024年龍年勳章

599^#

發表於 08-9-11 09:36 |只看該作者

yf:

請問net91, 胡上, 培基, 保良局朱正賢, siu漢森, 如果要排列, 你會點排?

==> 先講明, 上面我唔係每一間都暸如指掌的, 有d 我係靠自己聽唔同人, 睇唔同料收到的.....

咁多間之中, 朱仔朱正賢最受歡迎, 另同 group 蕭漢森跟後, 之後可考慮胡上, 培基唔多人提, 唔敢亂講.

私人傳訊