母乳餵哺 今日: 0 | 主題: 85707

積分: 1717

1^#

發表於 05-10-6 10:46 |只看該作者

嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

刋登自今日的都市日報:

嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳
據路透社報道,紐約羅徹斯特大學的一項研究顕示,嬰兒多喝母乳,會引致更多蛀牙.研究員利用一班幼鼠作測試,發現牠們喝人奶較喝牛奶而出現蛀牙的機會大.研究員建議,嬰兒最好在6個月大前才飲用母乳, 並應在生長出牙齒后暫停,免造成影響.(都市)

唔係牛奶甜d咩?!

私人傳訊回覆引用

chiuchristan

積分: 7768

2^#

發表於 05-10-6 10:59 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

Wa, there are many methods to prevent teeth decay. In my practice, I use to clean baby Hayes ' teeth with a soft baby towel or drink some water after drinking milk.

Hayes mama

Hayes had been breastfeeding for almost 3 years, then naturally weaned by himself！

Wish Hayes with Love, Peace & Joy！！

私人傳訊回覆引用

Lamblamb

積分: 2630

3^#

發表於 05-10-6 11:01 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

Wah!
I don't believe in the conclusion of this study!

They used rats to do the test - how can they apply what's happened to rats to us human beings?

Lulube was born weighing 3.2 kg

私人傳訊回覆引用

yuenwa

積分: 5774

4^#

發表於 05-10-6 12:03 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

不是人奶可以防止蛀牙嗎

私人傳訊回覆引用

calamus

積分: 1936

5^#

發表於 05-10-6 12:30 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

老鼠唔係飲老鼠奶咩??
呢個實驗係咪又係乜野奶粉公司資助呀??? :evil: :evil:

私人傳訊回覆引用

冰極

公爵府

積分: 25227

育兒性格勳章想生BB熱投好媽媽勳章醒目開學勳章畀面勳章 BK Milk勳章親子王國15週年勳章

6^#

發表於 05-10-6 13:06 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

我都有睇,唔明點解,如冇記錯之前唔知係咪世衛OR其他有報導講過都不是甘講既

俊曦網頁

[url=http://hk.myblog.yahoo.com

私人傳訊回覆引用

Glad

積分: 16387

好媽媽勳章醒目開學勳章

7^#

發表於 05-10-6 14:06 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

忙得很之時, 偶然上來巡巡, 看見這樣的研究, 不得不來說說我的理解.

當我看過這篇簡短的研究推論, 我感到是有必要去找來整個研究的詳細報導, 這是對作研究者公道, 也是讓讀者有更大的空間消化.

在未找來之前, 我的第一感想, 就是為什麼不是用配方奶, 而是用牛奶呢?

現時, 那有嬰幼兒不是吃母乳的就是吃配方奶(奶粉), 大多部分的配方奶的成分是取自牛奶, 但仍有很多其他添加成分, 包括令其味道甜美的配方. 我真想知道, 有多少個嬰幼兒是飲純牛奶的呢? 如有的發現, 請來分享.

一個不現實的比較, 就來斷定母乳比牛乳易於引致老鼠蛀牙, 就下結論------只可吃母乳至6個月大或開始長牙.

1. 注意口腔清潔就是的預防蛀牙的方法, 無論嬰幼兒是吃什麼, 照顧者都該做的事情, 管他是吃什麼, 也可做到同功能的預防功夫.

2. 直接餵哺母乳, 相對於瓶餵任何飲料, 這是最理想的減低蛀牙的機會. 大家理解一下, 寶寶要直接吸吮到母乳是需要含至乳暈部分, 母乳吸進時, 是避過了大部分的牙齒, 在齒蓬間留有母乳可謂是最低機會的. 我想問, 研究者是用什麼方式給老鼠吃母乳呢? (就此, 我建議大家當寶寶對刷牙的意願不高時, 讓寶寶以飲管進食有味道的飲料, 是可以大大減低蛀牙的機會.)

3. 已有研究指出, 母乳中的免疫蛋白球, 有助對抗細菌, 而且在吸吮過程中, 唾液會自然分泌, 當中的成分有抑制蛀牙的功能, 所以吃母乳的蛀牙機會是低於吃配方奶的.

待我有點時間, 一定找來有關該研究的詳細資料, 再來跟大家交流!

大家請放心, 繼續加油!

想想, 蛀牙是可以因為我們為寶寶清潔口腔而預防得到的一項由小培養的個人衛生的生活事務和習慣. 為什麼因為怕蛀牙就放棄最適合嬰幼兒吃的天賦人類糧食------母乳呢?

我可以敢說, 開始了副食品後, 要令寶寶蛀牙機會增加的不是母乳, 而是其他飲料和食物啊!

如果為了減低蛀牙機會, 就只吃母乳至6個月大或開始長牙時, 那麼請智慧高超的人類發明人可以飽肚又可得以維持健康和生命的方式, 令牙齒好好受寵一生不蛀吧!

願 【母乳餵哺資料庫】 保守著大家的母乳路 ! 無論順逆 , 願大家都以喜樂和盼望的心迎接喜與憂 ! 加油啊 ! 因為我們在這裡耕耘的路上 , 有的是扶持和關顧啊 ! 願 【母乳餵哺區】 是母乳家庭的加油站 !

私人傳訊回覆引用

Glad

積分: 16387

好媽媽勳章醒目開學勳章

8^#

發表於 05-10-6 14:21 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

我找來一篇報導, 與大家分享, 比"都市"的詳細.

FROM: http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/181_1509742,001100020006.htm

'Breast milk shows cavity-causing potential'

Reuters

New York, October 5, 2005

Though breastfeeding is sometimes seen as a way to protect against early cavities, a new study using rats suggests that breast milk may cause more cavities than cow's milk does.
However, researchers stress, breast milk appears no more likely to contribute to cavities than commonly used infant formulas and the animal findings should not be seen as a strike against breastfeeding.

Cavities can form when certain decay-causing bacteria in the mouth turn sugar into acids that damage the protective enamel on the teeth.

Not surprisingly, the new study found that sweet liquids like soda and honey- or sugar-sweetened water promoted dental erosion and cavities in baby rats. But while animals fed human milk showed far less tooth decay than those given such sugary drinks, they did develop more cavities than rats fed cow's milk.

"Breast milk has been presumed to be protective against cavities," said study co-author Dr Ruth A Lawrence of the University of Rochester in New York.

But the current findings suggest this is not the case, she said, and they point to a potential problem in allowing older babies to breastfeed throughout the night.

Lawrence and colleague Dr William H Bowen report their findings in the October issue of the journal Pediatrics.

In general, experts recommend that babies be fed only breast milk for about the first 6 months of life, and that breastfeeding continue after the introduction of solid foods, until at least the age of 12 months.

Breastfeeding throughout the night before the age of 6 months when babies need to feed more frequently, and have not yet gotten their first teeth is not a problem, according to Lawrence.

But allowing older babies to feed throughout the night might be, she said, particularly if a child is at greater risk of cavities because of a high prevalence of the problem in the family.

Parents are already advised not to put babies and toddlers to bed with a bottle, in order to protect their teeth from prolonged contact with the sugars in formula or any other liquids. In addition, Lawrence and Bowen write, when a nipple of the human or bottle variety stays in child's mouth for a long period, it may obstruct the flow of saliva, which is a natural cavity fighter.

It's not certain why breast milk was more cavity-promoting in this study than cow's milk was, but the researchers offer some possible explanations. Human milk, they note, contains more lactose, a milk sugar, than the cow variety does, and the mineral content of cow's milk which has more calcium and phosphorus may be less likely to demineralize tooth enamel.

However, Lawrence pointed out, babies should not be given cow's milk before the age of 1 year. Moreover, based on past research on infant formulas, breast milk appears no more likely to promote cavities than commonly used formulas are, she said.

"There are many health benefits for promoting breastfeeding in infants," Bowen and Lawrence conclude in the report. "Switching from breastfeeding to cow milk," they add, "is not being advocated here."

私人傳訊回覆引用

Glad

積分: 16387

好媽媽勳章醒目開學勳章

9^#

發表於 05-10-6 14:39 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

又找來 Pediatrics 的相關網頁, 簡介該項研究.

Comparison of the Cariogenicity of Cola, Honey, Cow Milk, Human Milk, and Sucrose
(http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/content/abstract/116/4/921)

私人傳訊回覆引用

ahgooma

別墅

積分: 715

10^#

發表於 05-10-6 14:52 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

報導片面 , 斷章取義!

都市日報

Time flies, my kids are 12 and 10 years old now

私人傳訊回覆引用

evamama

積分: 6225

11^#

發表於 05-10-6 15:25 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

glad,

多謝你出手相助, 又知多更多母乳知識了!!

我覺得大家對母乳若有疑問, 應多些拿出來分享, 錯的資料要加以更正, 正確的訊息要多加傳閱.

私人傳訊回覆引用

suilangmui

禁止訪問

積分: 14553

12^#

發表於 05-10-6 15:30 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除內容自動屏蔽

私人傳訊回覆引用

supergirl

積分: 1717

13^#

發表於 05-10-6 18:05 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

"都市"的簡甜報導好似與原本的研究距離很大bor....

多謝glad 登出原文!

私人傳訊回覆引用

gigiso

積分: 3684

14^#

發表於 05-10-6 18:46 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

真係搞笑!! 點解要搵老鼠來做實驗及跟人比較!
埋身餵啜時d奶根本唔經過d牙齒, 而且母乳抗菌, 點會比奶粉更易引致註牙???
簡直無良既奶粉商呀!!

私人傳訊回覆引用

sweetma

別墅

積分: 930

15^#

發表於 05-10-7 09:47 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

wa wa wa
thank Glad

it was so misleading
the English version seems to have very different meaning

私人傳訊回覆引用

貞貞

積分: 5849

16^#

發表於 05-10-7 10:26 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

好多謝Glad搵出完整研究報導, 睇完真係覺得都屎日報好唔啱, 斷章取義, 單是個topic 已經好有誤導性

私人傳訊回覆引用

stephenietam

侯爵府

積分: 23056

17^#

發表於 05-10-10 13:40 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

I was so scared when I saw this topic~~

私人傳訊回覆引用

chiuchristan

積分: 7768

18^#

發表於 05-10-10 14:44 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

Glad,
Thank you so much to show us the relevant articles which proved and supported us to walk on the breastfeeding road confidently, smoothly and encouraging.
God bless!

Hayes mama

Hayes had been breastfeeding for almost 3 years, then naturally weaned by himself！

Wish Hayes with Love, Peace & Joy！！

私人傳訊回覆引用

Glad

積分: 16387

好媽媽勳章醒目開學勳章

19^#

發表於 05-10-18 13:08 |只看該作者

Re: 嬰兒6個月大后應禁食人奶母乳

感謝大家! 面對這些報導, 縱然多忙也要盡點力啊.

報導精簡而造成誤導, 實是可悲!
在我們身邊經常會聽到或看到不少消息或建議, 教我們知道了會作出考慮.

我之所以走進互聯網的世界, 就是在兒子餵到10個月時, 一直欣賞和支持我母乳育兒的老師說, 看見有研究報導說不宜久餵母乳, 因為她沒有詳看沒有資料, 於是我就第一次為了母乳而上網找該報導, 可以卻找不到, 而走進寶貝花園, 卻認識到好豐富的具體母乳知識, 自始就更令我和兒子的母乳路自然地走進至今天.

每次遇到類似的研究發現時, 我會先以平常心去找盡量找較詳盡的報導, 甚至最理想是第一手的報告.

我相信人類智慧是有限制, 但卻是有著無窮潛能的發展, 為自身的健康作出不斷求進的研究.

當一種糧食被發現不宜人類進食之時, 去理解研究者所提出的是真確的理據證明, 我也得面對現實而放棄.

大家加油啊!

私人傳訊回覆引用

Jac